Do Some Industries Never Get Organic Gold Stars?

More threads by JoyHawkins

JoyHawkins

JoyHawkins

Administrator
Local Search Expert
LocalU Faculty
Joined
Aug 23, 2014
Messages
5,345
Solutions
47
Reaction score
2,837
I was talking to a client today who has correctly implemented review aggregate schema and the site looks perfect if you run it through the Rich Snippit tool. It also shows the stars when you do a site:domain.com search.

However, when you search the keywords he ranks for, there are no stars. He interestingly noticed that all his competitors also don't have stars. In fact, Yelp and Facebook don't have stars either.

The industry he's in is staffing agency/temporary agency.

Search any combination of staffing agency + city and I can't find a single listing with stars organically.

Is it possible that Google refrains from showing stars for certain industries?
 
Joy you always ask such great questions!

I have not looked into this but am anxious to hear what others have to say.
 
Yelp has 1 star for randstad
Screen Shot 2016-06-07 at 8.39.22 PM.jpg

Screen Shot 2016-06-07 at 8.39.22 PM.jpg
 
As far as on-site review schema is concerned, you probably right, some industries do not get stars from it. I have not seen a single car dealership with stars coming from schema. Although, iframing reviews from an industry focused review site seem to work for that. So, I do have a few dealers who have "customer review" pages ranking for "dealer name" + "reviews", and showing stars in search.
 
Never ever looked at recruitment and I cant find any showing review rich snippets in the UK ..... interesting
 
Just asked John Mu and he is not aware of any filter being applied to industry. He did say that they don't like if the review markup is sitewide or on irrelevant pages. Also they don't like if testimonials are used within the markup.
 
Let me ask Greg Gifford if he has ever seen them in auto.
 
Yep - we see it in Auto, cause we put the schema on our sites... but it's not review schema only, it's product markup (which includes reviews).

We feed in reviews of the specific model from Edmunds.com, then put product markup on the car and include the reviews OF THAT PRODUCT...

even then, it doesn't show up 100% of the time - but it shows more often than not, and obviously it stands out...

when you try to do it just with reviews of the business, it doesn't work...
 
Thanks Greg, I meant business review stars. I do see product-related stars.
P.S. there is a way to add business review starts. Not ideal.
hmreviews.jpg

hmreviews.jpg
 
My thinking is that there is not a filter on this industry (or any industry). I think that the reason we're not seeing stars in this industry are:
  • This isn't a particularly SEO savvy industry. Not many businesses will have added the markup.
  • You need to have decent domain authority for the stars to show.
  • The aggregate schema is easy to mess up. Many people implement it incorrectly and don't get the stars. The JSON version is so much easier. We have a post on our site about it.
 
Okay I think it's safe to say it's not the industry :)

What I noticed with this guy (we implemented review schema) is that when you search a keyword, the stars don't show HOWEVER when you search site:www.hissite.com you see the review schema and also it's correct when you look at the rich snippit tool.

Does anyone know why that might be? I'm perfectly fine with PM'ing anyone the site if they want to have a look.
 
That tells me it's a domain authority issue. Just not enough authority to push those stars. Also, the schema shouldn't be on the homepage or site-wide. If it's the homepage that's ranking, and not a subpage, then that would also explain it.
 
@Joy

What brother Darren said. Also, as he alluded to, a homepage never gets rich-snippet review stars. Hasn't for about 4 years now.
 
Thanks guys. We definitely didn't add any to the homepage. Just the location pages.
 
In that case, it's probably a lack of page authority (links). Look for opportunities for better internal linking to those pages, and see if you can get some external links to them.
 
Hey Joshua,

I kind of stopped looking into it but the business I was initially looking at still doesn't have the gold stars. I think it's probably due to what Darren said - their site lacks authority.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

MrHusky
  • Question
GA4 Organic Traffic Switched to Direct Traffic
Replies
3
Views
15K
MrHusky
MrHusky
djbaxter
Schema.org vs. Google's Structured Data Rich Results
Replies
0
Views
2K
djbaxter
djbaxter
djbaxter
How to Delete a Google Review
Replies
1
Views
4K
Jim Werth
J
djbaxter
Christmas video on SEO from John Mueller
Replies
0
Views
2K
djbaxter
djbaxter
georgebizpro
State of SEO industry: a vent post
Replies
8
Views
6K
HoosierBuff
H

Login / Register

Already a member?   LOG IN
Not a member yet?   REGISTER

Events

LocalU Webinar

Newest Posts

Trending: Most Replies

Trending: Most Viewed

  Promoted Posts

New advertising option: A review of your product or service posted by a Sterling Sky employee. This will also be shared on the Sterling Sky & LSF Twitter accounts, our Facebook group, LinkedIn, and both newsletters. More...

Share this page

Top Bottom