More threads by Giovanni Rosso

Joined
Jun 24, 2021
Messages
26
Reaction score
7
Hi everyone,

I am looking for advice on the safest verification workflow for a client's short-term rental listing in Milan, Italy, which is currently stuck in a tricky spot.

Here are the details of the listing: Business Name: Apartment Design a Milano Famagosta Forum with parking Current Address on GBP: Via del Mare, 49, 20142 Milano MI, Italy Maps Link: https://maps.app.goo.gl/p3UmPzsusKnodxWn8

The situation has two main complications:

  1. Previous failed video verification: The owner already attempted a video verification before contacting me, and it failed (I do not have details on how that first video was recorded or what was shown).
  2. Street number mismatch: The listing was mistakenly set up at street number 49, whereas all official municipal short-term rental authorizations (CIN / regional and national rental codes), utility bills, and legal documents are registered at street number 47 (Via del Mare, 47).
Since short-term rentals / vacation apartments are already heavily scrutinized by Google regarding permanent signage and eligibility, I want to avoid triggering a hard suspension or getting stuck in an endless verification loop.

Thank you all!

Giovanni
 
Hi Tony, thanks for the quick reply and the link to the guidelines.

It has been a while since I last focused on this, and I read that this restriction is a relatively recent change—even though this specific profile has already been active for quite some time—so I am just trying to figure out what is actually going on here.

When looking at Google Travel and Google Maps in Milan (and even in small towns here in Italy) under the "Vacation rentals" filter—like in this search link: https://www.google.it/travel/search?q=Milano&ts=CAISCgoCCAMKAggDEAA&ved=0CAAQ5JsGahcKEwiQ-dDHjZKYAxUAAAAAHQAAAAAQYw&ictx=3&qs=CAAgACgA&ap=MAA and the two screenshots attached—the map is packed with hundreds of individual apartments showing live nightly rates, property details, and pink house pins.

casa vacanza 2.webp


casa vacanza.webp


What confused me is that if I search for a few of those exact names in regular Google Search, some of them trigger a right-hand Knowledge Panel, and if I look them up inside the GBP creation/claiming dashboard, the system actually allows me to initiate a "Claim this business" flow for them.

From a technical standpoint, do you know how Google handles those pins? Are they purely auto-generated via OTA/channel manager feeds (Google Vacation Rentals / Hotel Center) that simply surface as unverified/claimable entities in the underlying Maps database, or are they legacy listings that remain visible until someone triggers a verification or suspension?

I want to give my client an accurate, compliant answer: is connecting through an approved connectivity partner / channel manager the only legitimate way for a single short-term rental to appear in those Map/Travel results without risking a GBP suspension?

Thanks again for your insight!

Giovanni
 
I don't know much about this subject, but I don't think it's a recent change that they're not allowed a GBP. The vacation rental search is completely different, those aren't GBP's. If some of them do happen to have a GBP, it's against the rules.

And as far as I know, yes, getting listed through an approved partner is the only way to get on the map.

I'm not even sure why you would want a GBP anyway, I think people are going to search for "vacation rental", etc. and the local finder won't even pop up.
 
Hi Giovanni,

Tony is right, and I’m sorry it’s not the answer your client was hoping for. Short-term rentals aren’t eligible for a Google Business Profile. Google’s guidelines exclude rental and for-sale properties, holiday homes included, and that rule has been there for years.

The confusing part is the one you spotted: Maps is full of them. Unfortunately, Google has tolerated these profiles for a long time, and in practice even encouraged them, since they verify, rank and collect reviews like any other business. Some are created at scale, often to feed secondary OTAs of doubtful quality. So it’s natural to assume they’re allowed. They aren’t; they just haven’t been removed yet.

That’s the real risk for your client. These profiles can be removed relatively easily. A report or a failed re-verification can be enough, and the reviews and photos go with it. So I wouldn’t spend time on a second video verification, and moving the pin from number 49 to 47 won’t change the eligibility problem.

On your question about the other pins: most of the vacation rental results in Maps and Google Travel aren’t Business Profiles at all. They come from a separate system fed by OTAs, channel managers and approved connectivity partners. That’s the compliant route for a single apartment: get listed through a booking site or channel manager that’s integrated with Google, and fix the street number there, at the source. The exception is a property manager or letting agency with a real office. The office can have a profile, but the individual apartments can’t.

There’s also a flip side that could be useful to you. Removing these profiles can be relatively easy, but time-consuming, so cleaning them up can be a service you offer your client. If competing rentals in his area are getting visibility through a Business Profile and its Knowledge Panel, a “Suggest an edit” report (Close or remove) is usually enough, and in my experience those edits get accepted. And it goes beyond a guideline technicality.

I’m from Mallorca, where illegal short-term rentals are a serious problem, and what I generally find is that these profiles belong to places with no short-term rental licence at all. Airbnb, Booking and the other OTAs have known about this for years, and in my view Google’s irresponsible approach to the issue has let all of them benefit from it. So I regularly clean up saturated locations around the island this way. Your client is licensed, which makes him the exception, and he’s precisely the kind of owner who benefits when the map is cleaned up. The DMA Law now makes Gatekeepers accountable for their actions, and we might have positive news on this issue next year.

Google-Maps-11-19-2026_08_37_AM.webp


Tim Capper explains the eligibility side far better than I can here:
https://onlineownership.com/google-...tals-holiday-homes-clearing-up-the-confusion/

Tim is a Google Product Expert and he’s always ready to help if you get stuck.

Google Hotel Center / Vacation Rentals documentation:
https://support.google.com/hotelpri...ef_topic=10062823&sjid=9661171528811440184-EU

Good luck with it!
 
Hi Lluc, hi Tony,

Thank you both so much for taking the time to explain this so clearly—especially Lluc for breaking down the whole picture and sharing those links.

I have been away from this specific area for a while, so I want to take a little time to study the documentation and dig into how the Hotel Center / Vacation Rentals feeds work before replying properly. Since I find this case really interesting—and I want to make sure I give my client/friend the best possible advice—I will definitely come back to this thread soon for a deeper discussion.

In the meantime, it looks like some kind soul (undoubtedly well-qualified) wasted no time in reporting and wiping out the profile after seeing the link in my first post. Well done, sheriff—Mountain View must be proud of you! Jokes aside, I actually get the frustration: I feel the exact same way whenever I stumble across spammy, unmaintained Google Maps virtual tours.

Thanks again for the help, and talk soon!

Giovanni

casa vacanza 5.webp
 

Login / Register

Already a member?   LOG IN
Not a member yet?   REGISTER

Events

GMBAPI

Our Brands

Back
Top Bottom