More threads by ganapathy

ganapathy

Member
Joined
Apr 25, 2019
Messages
49
Reaction score
10
Hi everyone,
We recently received what appears to be a fake negative review on our Google Business Profile and are seeking guidance on how to proceed further, as our previous actions have not been successful.
Details of the Review:
  • Reviewer Name: Don M
  • Review Text: “Horrendous customer service. No show guards, no clue operations centre. Disgraceful. Do not hire.”
  • Rating: 1 star
  • Business Name: Southern Cross Group Services
  • Maps Link: Google Maps Listing
  • Review Summary: View Review
We believe this review violates Google’s Contribution Policies, as it appears to be spam or fake engagement.

Actions Taken So Far:
  1. Reported the review as “Off-topic.”
  2. Replied to the review, inviting the reviewer to contact us — no response received.
  3. Submitted a formal request for removal via the Google Review Management Tool (Case ID: 3-9154000040316).
Response from Google Support:
Google Business Profile Support replied that the review “does not violate our policies” and therefore could not be removed.

Evidence Suggesting It’s Fake:
  • The same review text has been posted across approximately 15 different Google Business Profiles, spanning multiple locations and three different companies, including:
    1. Southern Cross Group Services
    2. Southern Cross Protection
    3. Southern Cross Investigations
  • Our company has no record of any customer interaction or engagement with this reviewer.
  • We are independent and not affiliated with Southern Cross Protection or any similarly named entities.
This pattern strongly suggests repetitive and misleading content, potentially violating Google’s guidelines on spam and fake engagement.
Any insights or recommendations from the community on how to escalate or effectively handle this situation would be greatly appreciated.

Thank you in advance for your support.

Same review text - 15 GBP - Spanning multiple locations.webp
 
Please post on the help forum.

Here is what you need to post:

The same person posts similar reviews on 15 of our locations. We flagged the reviews and have case ID: 3-9154000040316. Can these reviews be esclated for removal?

Make sure that you include the screenshot.
 
Please post on the help forum.

Here is what you need to post:

The same person posts similar reviews on 15 of our locations. We flagged the reviews and have case ID: 3-9154000040316. Can these reviews be esclated for removal?

Make sure that you include the screenshot.

Thank you for your guidance, @keyserholiday . I have now posted the issue on the Google Help Forum using the suggested content.

I have also attached the required screenshot in the post, as advised.

Please let me know if any additional details are needed.
 
A. You did copy and paste what I wrote as you are missing the link to the reviewer’s profile. Please removed the links to the forum as it violates the TOS here.
 
Ganapathy,
Good news that Google took the one on your listing down after the Product Expert escalation.
The same wording was also on about 15 profiles across three company names, including Southern Cross Protection and Southern Cross Investigations. You said you're not affiliated with those. I'd check whether any of those copies are still up. If they are, report them as repetitive or fake engagement and tell Google the identical text already came down from your profile after a Product Expert escalation. Your case ID (3-9154000040316) and the reviewer profile should help show it's the same pattern.
If you first reported yours as "Off-topic" and Support said it didn't violate policy, lean on that repeated identical text across businesses and locations this time. They already said no to the off-topic reason, and they weren't convinced by the fact you had no customer record under the name Don M.
Save the exact review text, the name as shown, and a note that the third appeal plus the Product Expert escalation is what finally worked. You'll want that if the same account or the same wording turns up again.
Julie
 

Login / Register

Already a member?   LOG IN
Not a member yet?   REGISTER

Events

GMBAPI

Our Brands

Back
Top Bottom