HoosierBuff

Member
Joined
Dec 12, 2013
Messages
313
Reaction score
86
I have a client who was told by their previous SEO firm that they had spammy links, and had a penalty (or maybe they just said, "at risk" for a penalty).

The client then built a brand new site, at a new url, and kept the old site up, but, did not redirect it.

As far as evidence that there was a penalty, there is nothing in Webmaster tools, and I can't find anything conclusive in their organic traffic history. Moz's open site explorer finds some bad links in there, but, not really that many.

Its now 18 months later, and I'm working on their SEO, and I kind of would like to redirect that old site. The risk is, that if I do this, and there is a penalty, I will penalize the new site.

My thinking is: If I redirect the old site, and get a penalty, can I just turn off the redirect?
 

Marie Haynes

LocalU Faculty
Joined
Aug 7, 2012
Messages
133
Reaction score
95
Hi.

I think that the main issue here is in the word "penalty". There are two types of penalties that could be in play here. One is a manual action for unnatural links. The second is not technically called a penalty, but sure acts like one and that would be if the site were affected negatively by Google's Penguin algorithm.

So let's say the site had a manual action. If the penalty is still active, you will see it when you go to Google Search Console - Search Traffic - Manual Actions. If you see "no manual webspam actions" there then there is no manual penalty. Now, it's possible that there *was* a penalty in the past and it has expired. But, if there is nothing showing in the manual actions viewer then there is no manual penalty currently on the site.

But, if it was Penguin, then this is tougher to diagnose. Google does not send out messages in GSC for Penguin hits. It happens algorithmically and you will see no messages or notifications. In most cases we can see a drop in organic traffic that coincides with a known or suspected Penguin rerun. But, sometimes this is hard especially if a site was not ranking really well to start with. (In other words, if Penguin caused a drop from #4 to #14 for a keyword you may not see much in analytics because you likely weren't getting a lot of clicks at position #4.)

If the site has spammy backlinks and you redirect it to the new site (whether you use a 301, 302 or other redirect), then all of those bad link signals will be redirected to the new site. So, if Penguin is considering the old site as untrustworthy in regards to its backlink profile, then redirecting it will likely cause the new site to drop in rankings. It could happen immediately or it could happen the next time Penguin updates. You will *not* get a message in Google Search Console to tell you that this has happened.

You do not want to risk redirecting a Penguin hit site to a good site.

You have a few options:

1) Do a thorough link audit and disavow. File the disavow for both sites. This may be good insurance against a hit. But, if the site has had a LOT of spam it's possible you may not be able to find all of the bad links to disavow them.

2) Do a redirect that doesn't pass pagerank..but that's tricky. I wrote an article about possible solutions here. The redirect that goes through an intermediary page blocked by robots.txt is the best solution, but it's tricky:

https://searchenginewatch.com/sew/h...users-from-a-penguin-hit-site-to-a-new-domain

Hope that helps. It's a complicated situation for sure.
 

Linda Buquet

Moderator
Local Search Expert
Joined
Jun 28, 2012
Messages
13,313
Reaction score
4,241
Thanks so much for weighing in Marie! We always appreciate your insights!
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
Y Manual Penalty for Organic, but why is GA flatlining for all other traffic? Organic SEO 11
Linda Buquet Definitive Guide to Recovering ORGANIC Google Penalty Organic SEO 0
Linda Buquet How to Diagnose Organic Penalties and Traffic Drops Organic SEO 1
Rich Owings Does "near me" optimization bring more organic or GMB clicks? Organic SEO 4
H The weirdness of organic results for certain queries Local Search 3
S Best Tips for Organic Traffic Organic SEO 3
L Issues With Bulk Verification for Enterprise Organization Multi-Location Issues 1
B Ranking High Organically but Low in The Local Pack Local Search 4
F GMB Practitioner Listings vs Organization Listing Google Duplicates & Merges 7
A Help Client gets "Invitation failed (Role not allowed)" when trying to add Organization ID Help & Support for Google Local 6
S Three pack, reviews, organic search decimated for SABs? Google My Business & Google Maps 8
V Local Services Ad: Does using a different phone number in local services ad effect the organic ranking for my site Paid Search and Local Service Ads 5
P Organization Access Trouble Help & Support for Google Local 2
L Majority of organic traffic outside US Local Search 1
K How to attribute PAID MAP Ads vs a ORGANIC MAP / GMB traffic Google My Business & Google Maps 12
J Can GMB Listings Strengthen Organic Results? Organic SEO 2
P Business ranks 4th in organic search but 13th in GMB, way behind rubbish competitors. Google My Business & Google Maps 6
Ellen Ranking in GMB and Local Pack - Not Traditional Organic Results Ranking Puzzles 4
BipperMedia Reviews being removed from "Education" organizations? Local Reviews 7
onebox220722 Buk Verification Problem ( Organization Account) Google My Business & Google Maps 1
M News Section at Top of Organic Search? Organic SEO 0
Rich Owings Are you seeing declining organic traffic for lodging sites? Local Search 7
pwarrenseo Disconnect Between Organic and Snack Pack Rankings Local Search 14
SteinCoffee Vast difference in location page organic rank when I don't add the location Local Search 2
Ellen Organization Has GMB Listing but Serves No Customers Google My Business & Google Maps 4
jared.ray Irrelevant Location Page in Organic Sitelinks Multi-Location Issues 1
S Sudden organic drop after a year of stability Organic SEO 12
L Best Approach to Claiming Yelp for Enterprise Organizations Citations 17
S Organic drop with server down? Organic SEO 10
Yan Gilbert Phone number in organic search Local Search 12
S Client disappeared in 3-pack & organic after GMB category priority change Google My Business & Google Maps 10
R Free Webinar: Organic Facebook Marketing Tips for Local Businesses Events 0
PaulSteinbrueck GMB listing has events for other organizations Google My Business & Google Maps 3
Meguinness Organic star ratings Organic SEO 3
schmeetz How to Properly Organize Practitioner Listings Under a Company Citations 5
A Strong in organic, poor in maps (rank jumps when you zoom in or out) Local Search 3
Brittany Barkes Could Being in a New Shopping Center Affect Organic Visibility? Organic SEO 4
J Organic Rankings Recovering From Medic; Local Still Not Improving Google Algorithm Discussions 7
Caroline Locksmith images on organic results Local Search 2
S Review stars in Google Organic: How is it Done? Local Reviews 29
S Dupe Post: Dramatic differences in Google Organic results Recycle Bin 0
S Dramatic differences in Google Organic results Google My Business & Google Maps 3
G Why do some city/services pages rank organically and others do not? Local Search 17
Kyrton Organic #1, exact same copywrite/meta Local Search 6
Tim Colling SEM Post: Google Local 3-Pack Drops Organic Listing for Local Ad Local Search 0
J Great organic rankings, but hit by Possum Local Search 8
D 4 Organic Results ABOVE Local Map Google My Business & Google Maps 5
S 3 Pack at bottom of page BELOW organic listings??? Local Search 1
Tim Colling Citations for a department of a larger organization Local Search 2
Marcus Local knowledge graph = organic position 1? Local Search 4

Similar threads

Login / Register

Already a member?   LOG IN
Not a member yet?   REGISTER

Most UpVoted Answers

LocalU Podcasts

  Promoted Posts

New advertising option: A review of your product or service posted by a Sterling Sky employee. This will also be shared on the Sterling Sky & LSF Twitter accounts, our Facebook group, LinkedIn, and both newsletters. More...
Google Product Exert


Top Bottom