standenman

Banned
1
Joined
Aug 2, 2012
Messages
103
Reaction score
5
Since the Google Pidgeon update my traffic has fallen off markedly. Pre-Pidgeon I had good 7- pack ranking with positive reviews. Post-Pidgeon I see a lot less of the 7-pack. I am ranking from #1 to #3 in the packless organic,and I would think that is good news. My experience, however, suggests that the 7-pack was more effective than high ranking without the 7-pack. For what it is worth! :)
 

Linda Buquet

Moderator
Local Search Expert
Joined
Jun 28, 2012
Messages
13,312
Reaction score
4,241
Thanks so much for sharing that Stan.

It's a topic that's often debated with opinions that vary widely.

Sorry it's caused your traffic to drop off.
 

valesence

Member
Joined
Jul 17, 2013
Messages
99
Reaction score
43
I also have had my traffic drop sharply. In my main city the 7 pack was reduced to 3 for some reason that I havn't figured out. Also I am not listed in that 3 pack for any search term. I am listed organically between spot 1-5 depending on keyword.

My thoughts on the traffic drop:

Being listed organically in many cases is lower than the packs. Lower listings get less traffic.

Organic listings do not show a star rating which for me is a huge disadvantage. I have worked very hard on getting reviews and at this point they do not help me at all.


At this point I believe traffic to my website has dropped 75%. I only hope that someone figures out why google ranks the business's they do in the local areas. There is actually a listing in the 3 pack for my target city that does not have a website, or a filled out google plus page or even a phone number. If google believes that an empty listing is the best thing to show, I am not sure what I need to do to be listed again.

My also believe that other search directories should be given more attention at this point. People doing local searches on google will begin to try other engines because I don't believe this update is going to give them what they were looking for.
 

standenman

Banned
1
Joined
Aug 2, 2012
Messages
103
Reaction score
5
High organic vs 7-pack: My Grassy Knoll Theory

Thanks for the feedback. Consider the difference between the SERP with a 7-pack or 3-pack with review stars, and the SERP without a pack. With the former I think the eye immediately goes to the stars and the 7-pack; with a regular SERP where does the eye go? The SERP is really just a list. The modest distinction of the
"Ad" icon with a yellow background I think is missed by most people. So where does the eye logically go with a "list" SERP? To the top, oh but wait, that is an adwords ad that makes Google more money. Hmm..
 

Linda Buquet

Moderator
Local Search Expert
Joined
Jun 28, 2012
Messages
13,312
Reaction score
4,241
Well there are advantages to being in organic and I've had other business owners say their traffic dropped way off when they got in the pack and they wanted their #1 organic listing back. (Back when all results were blended and you could not get lucky and have both.)

With organic, the listing is bigger, you get to craft the title tag the way you want it to read, with all the right keywords. And you get a description which can be compelling.

With a local listing you lose everything above, but of course gain the reviews, location data and map pin.

So I'm with you guys and think a local listing is better BUT it depended on what the consumer is looking for and what makes them click. More context? Bigger listing? Highest on the page listing? That call to action in the description? Or location on the map? Or reviews? Every consumer is different so it's hard to know what their hot button is.
 

standenman

Banned
1
Joined
Aug 2, 2012
Messages
103
Reaction score
5
That's a good point Linda, and thanks for the tip on the description. Think I'll try to spiff mine up!
 

Howell

Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2014
Messages
29
Reaction score
7
(Back when all results were blended and you could not get lucky and have both.)

Blended results can still happen, as I'm in 7-pack at C and organic #2.


attachment.php

Flux is going on...like daily.

blended.jpg
 

Linda Buquet

Moderator
Local Search Expert
Joined
Jun 28, 2012
Messages
13,312
Reaction score
4,241
Linda Said: (Back when all results were blended and you could not get lucky and have both.)

Sorry the way I said that was not very clear. I bolded to emphasize that before you could NOT get a double - in blended.

Blended to me was back when Google used to blend the organic and local into a single pack listing and you could not get a double.

Now the results aren't blended like that and usually the 1st 3 - 5 or so listings will be in both organic and the pack on page one.
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
Greg Bernhardt Is spending time on services worth it? Google My Business & Google Maps 3
S GMB image optimization - Worth it? Google My Business & Google Maps 1
ChristianRdz Is it worth changing http external backlinks to https? Organic SEO 2
M Internet Yellow Pages Listings Worth the Money? Paid Search and Local Service Ads 1
M Getting videos on page one worth it for Services? Organic SEO 2
L Is Yext worth the cost?? Citations 7
iFuse Geo-tagging Photos - Worth It? Google My Business & Google Maps 6
Tim Colling Google My Business Agency Dashboard - Is it worth switching yet? Google My Business & Google Maps 15
L Is it possible to get more that a 3 months worth of data from google my business ? Local Search 3
G Backlinks like local BBB and local area chambers of commerce worth paying for? Local Search 25
Garrett Sussman 7 Local Search Conferences Worth Attending Before the End of 2017 Local Reviews 2
Tim Colling Is it still worth it to share content to Google+ ? Local Search 11
M Stocks Waste in revenues (plastic recycling plant) worth $15.00 Recycle Bin 0
M Stocks Waste in revenues (plastic recycling plant) worth $15.00 Recycle Bin 1
J Are all those Citations available to Submit to on Bright Local worth it ? Citations 7
CodyBaird SEO Spending Could Be Worth 80 Billion by 2020 Organic SEO 6
L BBB Accreditation, worth it? Consultant's Corner 13
T Multi-location businesses: Is it worth doing Moz Local for each one? Multi-Location Issues 9
Tim Colling Multi-location businesses: Is it worth doing Moz Local for each one? Multi-Location Issues 9
Christa Morgante Is it worth linking out to your G+ Page on a website? Google My Business & Google Maps 3
T Is Google's Street View | Trust Photographer Program Worth It? Google Business View 8
Travis Van Slooten Is Google's Street View | Trust Photographer Program Worth It? Google My Business & Google Maps 8
M Is it even worth the hassle dealing with a locksmith? Local Search 7
Linda Buquet Local Search Pros - How do you Prove your Worth to Clients? Consultant's Corner 3
F Forum Signature Backlinks - Is it worth the risk if they're relevant? Local Search 7
jason2004 Is Neustar/Localeze worth $297/ Local Search 13
MiriamEllis Is G+ Local Sentiment Analysis Worth A Hang? Really? Local Search 4
Bernadette Coleman Looking For High Level PPC Expert. Paid Search and Local Service Ads 0
B Ranking High Organically but Low in The Local Pack Local Search 4
djbaxter Ninja Forms WordPress Plugin: High Severity Vulnerability Patched Websites, Software, and Security 0
ianscott Contact Form 7 Datepicker - High Vulnerability Leads To Plugin Closure Websites, Software, and Security 1
A Analyze High CPC Local Search 1
LocalSEODat Hey Gang - if you get high volume of reviews and only reply to positive ones, is that a bad thing? Local Reviews 2
Ellen GMB Dashboard Data Highly Inflated -- Related to Barry Schwartz Inflated Impressions Article NAP, Categories, Dashboard Data 1
j_holtslander "Highly rated" with 1 review? + Missing "Service" Google My Business & Google Maps 3
H A practice with 1 practitioner, 2 GMB's, and 1 high ranking Google My Business & Google Maps 7
Dino Should I get rid of this high traffic page on my website? Organic SEO 5
JustinB High Ticket 3 Pack Professions Google My Business & Google Maps 7
H Why do these three out of town lawyers show up high? Ranking Puzzles 18
ValerieM Duplicate G+ page but ranks high - what would you do? Google My Business & Google Maps 8
Linda Buquet Rank High in Organic but Not in Local? Joy's Post at Search Engine Land Google My Business & Google Maps 16
J I don't get why this one ranks so high Ranking Puzzles 15
J I don't get why this one ranks so high Ranking Puzzles 15
Linda Buquet How To Do HIGH IMPACT Review Audits - Turn Bad Reviews Into Solutions - Miriam Ellis Local Reviews 0
Susan 51% say High Local Rankings Deliver Greater Response than Organic - BrightLocal.com Local Search 2
Linda Buquet Local SEO: Which Performs Better - High Pack or High Organic Rankings? Local Search 10
J High quality backlink service Recycle Bin 0
Linda Buquet Crazy High Conversion Rates via Phone - 75% of Calls from Mobile Now Local Search 0
L New Local Ranking Puzzle - Come Play: Why Ranks High! Ranking Puzzles 4
Linda Buquet New Local Ranking Puzzle - Come Play: Why Ranks High! Ranking Puzzles 4

Similar threads

Login / Register

Already a member?   LOG IN
Not a member yet?   REGISTER

Most UpVoted Answers

LocalU Podcasts

  Promoted Posts

New advertising option: A review of your product or service posted by a Sterling Sky employee. This will also be shared on the Sterling Sky & LSF Twitter accounts, our Facebook group, LinkedIn, and both newsletters. More...
Google Product Exert


Top Bottom