djbaxter

Administrator
Administrator
Moderator
Joined
Jun 28, 2012
Messages
3,511
Reaction score
1,654
Google reviewing Canadian locksmith listings after investigation reveals fake addresses, reviews
by Tyana Grundig, Makda Ghebreslassie, and Greg Sadler, CBC.ca
Jan 10, 2020
CBC Marketplace uncovers more than 80 Toronto area listings on Google Maps with bogus information

A Marketplace investigation into the locksmith industry uncovered a sprawling network of fake locations and fake five-star reviews cluttering local Google Maps in the Greater Toronto Area. ....

marketplace-birchmount-locksmith-location.jpg

This empty lot was what Gehrels and Marketplace found when they visited the address for Birchmount Locksmith listed on Google Maps. (David MacIntosh/CBC)

Marketplace
ultimately discovered that Locksmith Experts Corp. has previously responded to service calls placed with several fake Google locations, including Birchmount Locksmith, Brampton Locksmith, Rouge Locksmith, and Port Credit Locksmith.

The website of the Better Business Bureau (BBB) lists Locksmith Experts with an F rating and 11 complaints. It warns of a pattern of unresolved complaints against the company. On Yelp, the company has nine negative reviews; and Marketplace producers spoke with several dissatisfied customers who complained of unexpectedly high bills and, at times, shoddy workmanship. ....

[Regarding] those fake listings, Gur said his company didn't create them, adding "we do however accept subcontracted service requests from a number of other locksmiths for whom we are not responsible."

More than 80 fake locations in GTA alone
Marketplace's investigation shows that in the Greater Toronto Area, fake locksmith locations are flooding the market on Google Maps, so that when people search for a locksmith, it looks like there's one nearby.

After weeks of research, more than 80 locksmith locations in the Greater Toronto area were uncovered as fake. At those addresses, Marketplace found vacant lots, pharmacies, retail stores, shopping malls and even a country club.

While turning to Google makes searching for a neighbourhood locksmith seem easier than ever, Marketplace's attempts to link these seemingly independent businesses were mostly analog.

Marketplace called up dozens of locksmiths in the GTA that we found were not actually at the address listed and were using what appeared to be fake five-star reviews, including Certified Locksmith Etobicoke, Pape Locksmith and East York Locksmith Experts.

All of the fake locations answered the phone the same way: "Service, how can I help you?" We were also given the same price quote by almost every one: $29 for the service call, and $45 and up for the rest. 21 of the fake locations we called told us they were linked with FC Locksmith. FC Locksmith claims to be "one of the best locksmith companies in Toronto", and their website mentions branches all over Toronto, the GTA and Southern Ontario, as well as in Ottawa and Calgary.

However, FC Locksmith does not appear to use its company name in Google Maps location listings. ....

Tracking down the fake reviews
FC Locksmith is well-rated on Google Maps, with dozens of five-star reviews. But with some digging, it appears most of them are fake.

A five-star Google review by a Denver Cothron reads: "I got locked out of my car the other day, so I called in for 24-hour locksmith services. They responded right away and solved the problem." The problem is that the man smiling in the reviewer's profile picture is actually Toronto lawyer Ian Roland. "The picture's me, but nothing else is — and I have no idea how they got it," said Roland. .... Some of the other images attached to the fake Google reviews are photos of real-life professors, doctors and real estate agents — but with different names. A five-star review by someone named Dalton Fincher is actually an image of U.S. astronaut Clayton Anderson on the space shuttle Discovery. ....

The widespread use of fake locations by some locksmith companies came as no surprise to Mike Blumenthal, a U.S. search engine consultant and Google Maps local search expert.

"It's profitable and there's no real enforcement," he said. Blumenthal said fraudulent listings have been an ongoing issue for Google, particularly when it comes to local searches. The problem is more prevalent in some home services, such as locksmiths, appliance repair and garage door repairs, he said, suggesting as many as 85 per cent of local Google home services listings could be fake. "[People] call the locksmith on Google because they trust Google," said Blumenthal. "Legitimate businesses can't compete because a business that has collective resources to spam Google pushes them out."

Fake listings erode consumer trust in how to find a good local business — and in the online marketplace generally, Blumenthal said. And when things go wrong, it can make it hard for consumers to find those accountable. ....

Whoever is posting fake reviews may be in violation of Canada's Competition Act, the federal law that governs most business conduct in this country. The Competition Bureau tells Marketplace that "anyone who produces, sells or distributes fake endorsements or reviews could be liable under the [Competition] Act." ....

Blumenthal questioned whether businesses that are willing to cheat on their listings and reviews are also willing "to cheat at who they send out to repair. They could be sending people into your home that are not qualified to be there or shouldn't be there because of background issues," he said. ....

All of the fake locations uncovered in our investigation have since been removed.
@mblumenthal

Read more...
 

Tim Kahlert

Member
Joined
May 24, 2019
Messages
76
Reaction score
54
Read it this morning too. I think that´s not a big surprise as there are probably a few more to uncover I guess. It´s about time for Google to tidy up a bit.
 

djbaxter

Administrator
Administrator
Moderator
Joined
Jun 28, 2012
Messages
3,511
Reaction score
1,654
A followup article today in Search Engine Land:


In 2012, Yelp initiated a program called “consumer alerts.” Its objective was to notify consumers about “brazen attempts to manipulate ratings and reviews – either by purchasing/incentivizing people for reviews, writing a bunch of reviews from the same IP address . . . acquiring reviews from a deceptive review ring, or threatening reviewers with legal action.”

Yelp reviews for sale by geography

Screen-Shot-2020-01-10-at-2.20.02-PM-800x446.png

Now the company is stepping up efforts to stop “review rings,” which have become something of a cottage industry online. For example, the search query “where can I buy Yelp five star reviews?” lead me to Quora and in turn to AppSally, which is openly selling Yelp reviews (graphic above).

‘Suspicious review activity.’ Yelp is now introducing a new category of consumer alerts intended to flag businesses “that may have received reviews from deceptive review rings.” The company says that it closed “more than 400 user accounts associated with one vast review ring we recently uncovered.”

New ‘suspicious review activity’ alert on Yelp

Screen-Shot-2020-01-10-at-2.37.50-PM.png

Yelp explained that it engaged a third party to “evaluate the fraudulent review landscape for Yelp,” which apparently included trying to buy fake reviews. This analysis reportedly found:
  • A decline in fraudulent providers offering Yelp reviews for sale
  • 35 of 36 fraudulent review vendors had been caught by Yelp’s filtering software
  • Buying fake Yelp reviews is getting more expensive at the vendors still willing to sell them
A Yelp spokesperson asserted in an email to me that as fraud has been prosecuted on its platform, fake review vendors continue to operate and publish “on other platforms” (read: Google). For its part, TripAdvisor reported recently that it blocked or removed nearly 1.5 million fake reviews in 2018.
 

denis76682

Member
Joined
Jan 5, 2020
Messages
23
Reaction score
5
Read it this morning too. I think that´s not a big surprise as there are probably a few more to uncover I guess. It´s about time for Google to tidy up a bit.
I think so too....but lets see how it go...
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
Linda Buquet New Local Search Marketplace Launched Local Search 1
Linda Buquet Local MarketPlace Forum? Mod Squad 7
Margaret Ornsby Webinar: Uncovering the Benefits of Local Search Marketing Local Search 2
Niki Business category does not support more hours Help & Support for Google Local 2
S Site has higher DA and more backlinks than sites on 1st page and still not on 1st page Local Search 5
Rich Owings Does "near me" optimization bring more organic or GMB clicks? Organic SEO 4
djbaxter Google services down Dec 14, 2020: Google Ads, Google Analytics, Search Console, more Google News: Important Changes & Features 1
Eoghan_MFeed Looking for a SaaS but more importantly Local Search experienced product managers 🔍 Local SEO Job Board 0
nathangdavidson Is having more than one GMB listing actually against Google guidelines? Spam on Google 9
Chaddow More Hours feature within GMB Google My Business & Google Maps 5
Jorge User with more than 45 Spam Tokens Help & Support for Google Local 2
Ellen See More Hours - Clicking on this doesn't open panel in SERP Google My Business & Google Maps 1
JulJameson Who can tell me more? Recycle Bin 1
JoyHawkins Google Adds "Get More Reviews" Button in Knowledge Panel Google News: Important Changes & Features 3
A No More PIN Attempts - Reverification! Local Search 2
Cordell Crowley Google Beginning to Push Ads More in the GMB Dashboard Google My Business & Google Maps 1
M This location has been suspended due to quality issues. Learn more Contact Us Messages 1
Cordell Crowley GMB Phone Support No More? Google My Business & Google Maps 10
nathangdavidson Local Teaser SERP feature more common for mobile searches? Local Search 2
A No more email clue! Google My Business & Google Maps 26
H Adding MORE photos to a GMB profile - - any value Google My Business & Google Maps 25
BenFisher More Places to become More Businesses ? Google My Business & Google Maps 4
T More map views than search views Google My Business & Google Maps 1
Dan Foland Is anyone else noticing Google displaying more consecutive same-site results? Google Algorithm Discussions 6
Phil Rozek "More about [business]" dropdown in local knowledge panel: new? Google My Business & Google Maps 6
S Does Google penalize you for using the Event post hack to get your post to last more than 7 days? Google My Business & Google Maps 6
U Is Google creating more listings with data obtained from elsewhere Google My Business & Google Maps 6
Jeffrey How to get more engagement Google My Business & Google Maps 16
Tim Colling More spam Mod Squad 2
djbaxter Seeing more contact form spam? Contact Form 7 now requires reCaptcha 3 Websites, Software, and Security 0
F Why am I seeing more and more no website businesses rank in 3 pack Local Search 12
djbaxter Google Ignores Edu Links Because They Are Spammed More Organic SEO 7
djbaxter Google AdSense payment notification but more than two years old Break Room: Chat and Off Topic 0
djbaxter Google: New URL inspection tool & more in Search Console Organic SEO 0
Conor Treacy GMB Comparison Tool (& Facebook too) - Does it exist any more? Local SEO Tools & Software 1
Garrett Sussman 5 More Unique Email Templates for Requesting Online Reviews Local Reviews 4
L Is it possible to get more that a 3 months worth of data from google my business ? Local Search 3
Eric Rohrback This... This is where i'd like to see more of our industry go Consultant's Corner 1
Nikos Appointment URLs in more business types Google My Business & Google Maps 10
G More citations, better rating than competitors yet the ranking... Local Search 11
mborgelt Why Aren't More Local Pros Talking about Content Marketing? Organic SEO 6
liriotherapy Help with more local citation please Citations 2
vivekrpatel What holds more importance for Google Knowledge Graph? Google My Business & Google Maps 0
Creativedge 20-year-old Business disappeared from "More Places" Help & Support for Google Local 9
JoyHawkins What Aspects of Local SEO Would You Want More Training In? Consultant's Corner 9
C Getting Local Search Ads to Display More Often? Paid Search and Local Service Ads 10
A Lost more than 20 verified Google business pages for one day ! Google My Business & Google Maps 6
Durandl Dog walking business - No Brick and mortar location - Covering more than 1 location Local Search 5
Broland More Google Maps Updates? Google My Business & Google Maps 1
JoshuaMackens What's More Relevant, Local Links or Industry Links? Google My Business & Google Maps 19

Similar threads

Login / Register

Already a member?   LOG IN
Not a member yet?   REGISTER

Most UpVoted Answers

LocalU Podcasts

  Promoted Posts

New advertising option: A review of your product or service posted by a Sterling Sky employee. This will also be shared on the Sterling Sky & LSF Twitter accounts, our Facebook group, LinkedIn, and both newsletters. More...
Google Product Exert


Top Bottom