Joined
Oct 17, 2012
Messages
7
Reaction score
2
Hi gang, long time no post (interact, log in, engage etc) my bad...

the first time I encountered the phrase "over optimization penalty" was in a thread on the Warrior Forum 5 years ago. the OP cited several instances where in g Places serps where one of the combatants ( I call competitors combatants.. might be due to my being of Scottish decent ) had way, WAY more citations, incoming links, content than the others in a 3 pack or 7 pack

this person observed what could be construed as a possible Over Optimization Penalty being levied by big G

Fast forward 5 years, in the productforums.google.com google places forum a poweruser (I think it might have been mysqlperformance or Andrew something) suggested Google was a relational database, my take on that is this:

let's say there's 4 combatants vying for ranking in G places
and for the sake of argument, there's, say a total of 7 similar companies Google has identified as doing business in the same genre in the same location.

if all 7 have roughly 3 or 4 backliinks, and your client has 1867 backlinks...
and of the 4 attempting some sort of optimization, 3 have a Facebook and a yelp, but your client has 43 citations from the list on yext.com and getlisted.org (moz local now)... then your client would or could "stick out like a sore thumb"

what say you group?

is there such a thing, does anyone have any empirical or anecdotal evidence to support this as a "thing" ??
thanks

hmm, sig file...
David Bruce Jr
Frederick Maryland
Connect on Google+
https://plus.google.com/u/0/+DavidBruceJr/posts
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Linda Buquet

Moderator
Local Search Expert
Joined
Jun 28, 2012
Messages
13,312
Reaction score
4,241
Hi David,

Sure there are organic optimization penalties - those can kill your local ranking because you wont be at top of 7 pack unless you rank high in organic. (Can be backlink penalties or on-site penalties.)

Then separately there are Google Local over-optimization penalties and several things can trip a filter that knock you out of maps, which takes you out of the pack too.

RESULT: you may rank high in organic, may even be #1 but you'll be locked out of the pack and only rank in organic.

There are also what I call "Blend" penalties. This is one that throws folks cuz you can rank #1 in organic and #3 in maps so SHOULD be ranking high in the pack. But you don't. There's a penalty that prevents you from "blending" so you don't rank in the pack.

BUT there are other reasons you can be locked out of the pack like proximity, dupes and NAP confusion. So thorough analysis needs to be done to figure out if it's a penalty or something else.

Here is a good post: <a href="http://localsearchforum.catalystemarketing.com/google-local-important/14266-local-troubleshooting-best-practices.html">Local Troubleshooting Best Practices</a>
 

johncrenshaw

Member
Joined
Mar 14, 2013
Messages
77
Reaction score
54
Anecdotally, there is without a doubt plenty of over-optimization issues you can encounter - not so much penalties in the "wow I got dropped from #3 to #300" penalty, but more like ranking becomes an uphill battle where it might not have otherwise.


I don't think that your example of a client with so many links sticking out to Google over others just because of those links is an issue though. Google's gotten ridiculously good at identifying "quality content." If you're content sucks and you somehow get it ranking, it's likely that it will tank eventually. If you get that many more links than your competition, I don't think it's unreasonable that Google can tell those links are either gamed or not-gamed. If they were gamed, you'll probably be in rough shape...if not, you'll be fine.

So yes, I think there are definitely over-optimization penalties, but if you get links naturally there most likely won't be a problem, even if you're talking a lot of links.
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
Linda Buquet Over-Optimization Penalty for Local Sites Internal Links? Local Search 18
Rich Owings Does "near me" optimization bring more organic or GMB clicks? Organic SEO 4
C Help with service page optimization Organic SEO 20
Ben Walsh Near me on page optimization Ask a LocalU Expert [PRIVATE] (LocalU) 1
djbaxter Passage Indexing: Not A Core Update. It's Ranking, Not Indexing. Don't Optimize For It Google Algorithm Discussions 0
Andy Optimal positioning (for CRO) of reviews widgets on website Local Reviews 5
F Optimizing for local and online - broader areas? Local Search 0
Monica Simpson Optimizing Name - do citations matter? All Things Google My Business [PRIVATE] (LocalU) 7
Nicole Basham Multi-service Service Area Business: GMB Optimization Advice Needed Service Area Businesses 2
S GMB image optimization - Worth it? Google My Business & Google Maps 1
A What Wordpress Speed Optimizing Plugins do you use? Websites, Software, and Security 7
M Google Optimize? Google News: Important Changes & Features 2
bruce@brucejone Optimizing Images For GMB - Things Have Changed Google My Business & Google Maps 8
dave101 Looking for an SEO consultant with experience optimizing IT support companies Local SEO Job Board 1
dave101 Anyone have experience with optimizing IT Support companies? Service Area Businesses 0
Vincent Tobiaz Recent Study 3.6 min acceptable rating & 4.9 being most optimal Google My Business & Google Maps 3
BipperMedia How do you optimize for a specific kw please? Recycle Bin 0
S Review Request - Business Card - Text optimization? Google My Business & Google Maps 24
M How do you optimize for a specific kw please? Local Search 46
Paul Kargo Local Business for two Different Languages - How to Optimize? Recycle Bin 5
M Optimizing GMB questions please Google My Business & Google Maps 34
vivekrpatel Local Business for two Different Languages - How to Optimize? Local Content 7
Justin Mosebach TripAdvisor Optimization Tips? Local Search 8
vinchenson Would you change the name of a listing that is not optimized? Local Search 4
J Customer requesting help with SEO optimization for "Customer Name" Keyword Ranking Google Local 101 9
LilyRayNYC Practitioner page consistently outranking main biz page despite being less optimized Ranking Puzzles 2
M What info needs to go into optimized image?? Local Search 7
Tim Colling Home Care Voice Search Optimization: Alexa Echo Show 2 vs. Google Home Hub (The Winner is Yelp) Local Search 4
L Help optimize google my business Contact Us Messages 2
C Who REALLY Knows How Much "Optimization" Is Just Wheel Spinning Google My Business & Google Maps 10
Garrett Sussman How To Help Your Clients Optimize Their Review Site Listings [FREE PDF DOWNLOAD] Local Reviews 2
A New(ish) SEO and Website Optimization company Recycle Bin 0
Gsmithmike How do you optimize Local Landing pages? Organic SEO 8
Linda Buquet The Optimal Local Landing Page For Attorneys - NiftyLaw Local Search 1
Garrett Sussman How to Fully Optimize Your Google My Business Listing Local Reviews 0
Ryan77 100's of Page 1 Rankings Already - How To Better Optimize The Home Page? Local Search 11
James Watt Google's new mobile testing tool, plus some mobile optimization tips Local Search 1
bczubiak Is Your OnPage Optimization Working? Track Your Ranking Changes With Automation Consultant's Corner 3
L Bulk Optimizing Images - Wordpress Organic SEO 3
Linda Buquet Experts Share Tips: How to Optimize your Google My Business Listing Google My Business & Google Maps 1
L Optimizing Image Galleries Organic SEO 4
JoyHawkins How to Optimize 2 Locations in the Same City Local Search 5
bczubiak Non-English Website Optimization Local Search 3
Colan Nielsen Local Finder Photo Optimization Tips Google My Business & Google Maps 14
M Multiple location optimization Multi-Location Issues 4
M Multiple location optimization Multi-Location Issues 4
L Multi-Location Local SEO: Problems & Optimization Tips - 2 Part Series Multi-Location Issues 4
Linda Buquet Multi-Location Local SEO: Problems & Optimization Tips - 2 Part Series Multi-Location Issues 4
Linda Buquet Optimize for the NEW Local Centroid - The User! Miriam Ellis @ Moz Local Search 1
Linda Buquet 7 Under-the-Hood SEO Optimization Techniques | Neil Patel - Search Engine Journal Organic SEO 0

Similar threads

Login / Register

Already a member?   LOG IN
Not a member yet?   REGISTER

Most UpVoted Answers

LocalU Podcasts

  Promoted Posts

New advertising option: A review of your product or service posted by a Sterling Sky employee. This will also be shared on the Sterling Sky & LSF Twitter accounts, our Facebook group, LinkedIn, and both newsletters. More...
Google Product Exert


Top Bottom