mborgelt

Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2012
Messages
479
Reaction score
155
After the discovery of penalized sites still ranking in local, what is the tipping point of bad/spammy backllinks negatively effecting local rankings? The reason that I ask is that we have had several clients come to us with great on-site and off-site SEO but have a ton (ranging from 900-1,900) backlinks from completely unrelated sites. We have gotten some of these clients to rank well despite these setbacks without touching backlinks because their budget doesn't allow a good cleaning but others seem to completely hindered from moving past page 3. Most of these clients are in either DUI or PI Law. Any help is appreciated!
 

Linda Buquet

Moderator
Local Search Expert
Joined
Jun 28, 2012
Messages
13,312
Reaction score
4,241
Hi Michael,

Thanks for raising the question. Not sure there is a definitive answer and like most things it probably depends.

Did you see this post? <a href="http://www.localsearchforum.com/local-seo-ranking/28300-ranking-1-local-7-pack-even-though-panda-penguin-penalty.html">Ranking #1 in the Local 7 Pack - Even Though Panda or Penguin Penalty?</a>

It seems if you dig in and read the 2nd post I linked to as well, that there are many times that organic penalties don't affect pack ranking. But then again, I know sometimes it does. Not sure what causes one penalized site to drop out of the pack and another to remain though.

The mysteries of Google... :rolleyes:

Anyone else care to weigh in?
 

mborgelt

Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2012
Messages
479
Reaction score
155
Yes Linda that post is very insightful and part of the reason I posted this. We know nothing in this field is ever hard and fast but it's always nice when you have a benchmark where you can tell clients whether they should worry when you can. Which seems to be disappearing luxury haha.
 

Laustin1878

Member
Joined
Sep 27, 2012
Messages
412
Reaction score
40
Just curious, what makes you think there is a tipping point?

If you know that Google has been on a quest to punish sites who are getting unrelated links, why not develop a plan that helps build more quality links? This way, when those crap links get devalued, you still have a strong link profile?

My personal opinion is that Google will continue to get better at identifying unrelated links and will cast a wider net as they move along. If you haven't got caught yet and you are still engaging in this, it's only a matter of time. Not saying that you are doing this, just a general thought.
 

Marie Haynes

LocalU Faculty
Joined
Aug 7, 2012
Messages
133
Reaction score
95
I don't think there's a tipping point. I also don't think that having links from unrelated sites is necessarily bad in the eyes of Penguin. Penguin was designed to demote sites that are actively trying to manipulate Google.

So, my biggest concern would be to determine whether those hundreds of links were ones that were made for SEO purposes. If yes, then a backlink audit is a good idea. If no, then in most cases you can ignore them.

Also, as Linda mentioned, a site can be affected by Penguin organically and not locally. And one final thing to know is that Penguin can hit sites to different degrees. It doesn't always have to be catastrophic. So, if there are bad links there and your client is ranking, say #9 organic, then there is a possibility that a link cleanup could make a big difference.

My reason to say this is to say that rather than thinking of Penguin as an algo that is "on or off" and has a tripping point, think of it like a filter that takes into account the overall trust level that Google has in a site's backlink profile.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Linda Buquet

Moderator
Local Search Expert
Joined
Jun 28, 2012
Messages
13,312
Reaction score
4,241
My reason to say this is to say that rather than thinking of Penguin as an algo that is "on or off" and has a tripping point, think of it like a filter that takes into account the overall trust level that Google has in a site's backlink profile.

Quoting you and repeating that Marie, because I think it's important and well said!

Thanks so much for weighing in.
 

Dave

Member
Joined
Nov 19, 2012
Messages
254
Reaction score
78
Marie is a real expert on this stuff. She helped me.

I'd agree entirely with her comments.

Links from unrelated sites could be there for "related reasons" of some sort.......or they could be unnatural and unrelated and possibly for ranking purposes only.

If one is a chiropractor and happens to write in a manner about something that ties topics of that issue with child rearing or diet, its possible mommy blogs and foodie blogs could pick up the interesting article and give the chiropractor practice a lot of links.

Hey that is reasonable. Its also clever. If the article is credible it should pass "google muster". Possibly. Probably, but not 100% guarantee with their filters and analyses.



If your a chiropractor and you have 100's or thousands of links with no credible relationship than it can cause a penalty.

Now if a dui attorney is in a small town and there are 3,4, or 5 competitors than being on the third page for "target town/dui attorny type search phrase is, I would suggest, a sure sign of a penalty.

If the DUI attorney is in a big city and there are 90 competitors, being on the third page versus the first page, needs lots and lots more analysis.

Its quite possible that regardless of the above the dui attorney could still hit the pac.
 

Linda Buquet

Moderator
Local Search Expert
Joined
Jun 28, 2012
Messages
13,312
Reaction score
4,241
Haha! Just picked up a great quote from Andrew Shotland at SMX.
Fits in this post...

“Links don’t kill websites. People kill websites!” :)
 

mborgelt

Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2012
Messages
479
Reaction score
155
Sorry it took me a while to respond to all of your responses. I am speaking about potential clients coming to us with completely unrelated links and large amounts of them. As with most things in this industry it looks like it's a case by case basis. Just seeing if something more interesting was happening but thanks, all.
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
S Best Tips for Organic Traffic Organic SEO 3
F Do You hate Writing Content? Here Are Some Tips to Ease the Pain. Recycle Bin 0
BWrightTLM Yelp Business Listing Tips Local Reviews 4
Justin Mosebach TripAdvisor Optimization Tips? Local Search 8
djbaxter Google: Tips for responding to reviews Google My Business & Google Maps 0
R Free Webinar: Organic Facebook Marketing Tips for Local Businesses Events 0
PaulSteinbrueck Contribute a tip about online reviews? Contact Us Messages 0
Colan Nielsen Image Thumbnails on Mobile: How To Get Them (Awesome Tips) Local Search 2
Garrett Sussman Wedding Industry Review Management Tips & Insights Local Reviews 0
Garrett Sussman Realty Industry Review Management Tips & Insights Local Reviews 0
Garrett Sussman Healthcare Industry Review Management Tips & Insights Local Reviews 2
Garrett Sussman Hospitality Industry Review Management Tips and Insights Local Reviews 0
Garrett Sussman Legal Industry Review Management Tips & Insights Local Reviews 0
Garrett Sussman Home Services Industry Review Management Tips & Insights Local Reviews 2
T Client Getting Review Spammed Like Crazy - Any Additional Tips? Local Reviews 11
Eric Shanfelt VIDEO TIP: How to Make a Direct Google Reviews Link Local Reviews 4
Garrett Sussman 7 Simple Tips to Inflate Your Marketing Agency's Perceived Size Local Reviews 0
J Some Local SEO tips for ranking in London? Local Search 0
S Tips Wanted To Improve My YouTube Subs Local Search 0
H Google Images associated with GMB. Getting worse? Any new tips Google My Business & Google Maps 3
H Tips for avoiding the Hall of Shame and the wrath of the SEO Police? Spam on Google 3
Garrett Sussman 5 Tips to Strengthen Your Reputation Management Strategy and Boost Your SEO Local Reviews 0
James Watt Tip for adding schema to a wordpress site with Yoast Local SEO Tools & Software 16
JoyHawkins 201 Actionable SEO Tips Organic SEO 1
James Watt Google's new mobile testing tool, plus some mobile optimization tips Local Search 1
Garrett Sussman Hug Your (Online Review) Haters: Tips From Jay Baer's Best Selling Book Local Reviews 4
JoyHawkins 34 Experts Share Their #1 Actionable Local SEO Tip Local Search 4
Linda Buquet Experts Share Tips: How to Optimize your Google My Business Listing Google My Business & Google Maps 1
timcapper Citation Tips for Dubai and UAE Citations 0
Linda Buquet 73 SEO Experts Share Penguin Penalty Removal Tips Organic SEO 3
L Critical Google Local Dupe Research Tips: New Tool & New Trick Google Duplicates & Merges 9
Linda Buquet Critical Google Local Dupe Research Tips: New Tool & New Trick Google Duplicates & Merges 9
Colan Nielsen Local Finder Photo Optimization Tips Google My Business & Google Maps 14
D Do You hate Writing Content? Here Are Some Tips to Ease the Pain. Local Content 5
Dustybones Do You hate Writing Content? Here Are Some Tips to Ease the Pain. Local Content 5
L 3 Tips for Developing Locally Focused Blog Content - From a Local Content Writer Local Content 3
Linda Buquet 3 Tips for Developing Locally Focused Blog Content - From a Local Content Writer Local Content 3
Linda Buquet 90 SEO Experts Share their Best White Hat Link Building Tips - Ahrefs Blog Organic SEO 2
Dustybones Got A bad Review? Here Are Some Tips on How to Deal With It Local Reviews 3
Dustybones 5 Great Tips to Improving Your Schema Markup Local Search 1
L Getting Content from Local Clients is Like PULLING TEETH! Part 2 - More Tips Local Content 2
Linda Buquet Getting Content from Local Clients is Like PULLING TEETH! Part 2 - More Tips Local Content 2
Linda Buquet 17 Tips to Help You Measure Local Search ROI & Keep Your Clients! Joy Hawkins Consultant's Corner 4
Colan Nielsen Great Keyword Research Tip Local Search 6
Linda Buquet Local Video SEO Making You Craz-EO? Here are some tips Marketing 0
CaseyMeraz Competitive Analysis Tips for Local SEO Local Search 2
L Getting Content from Local Clients is Like PULLING TEETH! Tips, Tricks & Tools Local Content 0
Linda Buquet Getting Content from Local Clients is Like PULLING TEETH! Tips, Tricks & Tools Local Content 0
Dustybones URL Structure Tips From Gary Illyes Local Search 6
Linda Buquet 10 Content & Copywriting Tips for Dentists that Put you Ahead of the Pack Local Search 0

Similar threads

Login / Register

Already a member?   LOG IN
Not a member yet?   REGISTER

Most UpVoted Answers

LocalU Podcasts

  Promoted Posts

New advertising option: A review of your product or service posted by a Sterling Sky employee. This will also be shared on the Sterling Sky & LSF Twitter accounts, our Facebook group, LinkedIn, and both newsletters. More...
Google Product Exert


Top Bottom