Hey Nick!
tl;dr: Use GA to pull Landing Pages from SEO. Leads/orders on different sections based on city. Make sure to give context to your numbers, and that they are meaningful to / actionable for the client. Don't "pad out" a report just to make it look bigger; the most valuable reports are short and meaningful.
What I push for is for the agency to provide data that is meaningful to the business, and this changes often. The list that
@JoyHawkins gave is great, and very similar to what we ask for. I think reporting should come in two parts: metrics and work.
The metrics side should show 1) the key metrics that you agreed on, with the client, as the important growth factors. 2) it should give meaningful context to the numbers (growth vs. a comparable period). It should also relate to the work you are doing/have done for them.
In addition to your mentioned GMB Insights, pull a Google Analytics report of the Landing Pages, filtered to only show organic traffic from their local area. This will help them see what content on their site is working to drive traffic that could convert with them (best for companies who only serve the local area; if they sell nationally, then report nationally). You should also be showing them what parts of the site are working in different geographies, in case there are certain areas which are being underserved.
In addition to metrics reporting, include those things Joy talked about in points 2-3. Your report should be bespoke and sepcific to the needs and work of the company.
I like when an agency can explain the following points:
- What information you saw in the analytics that shows an opportunity for growth
- What work you are going to do to take advantage of that opportunity
- When that work will be completed
- What will be considered success
- When you will be able to see and share the success
I.E. "We looked at the numbers and saw that in this area, we aren't getting a ton of traffic to SECTION A of the site from SEO. We think that by updating the following pages with new images and text, we can improve the rankings and ultimately drive more organic traffic to that page. We should be able to get the content written and implemented this month, and should start to see the rankings & traffic improve 1-2 months after that".
Don't just "pad out" a report with metrics unless they are meaningful. The more junk you give them, the more they will get distracted from what is really important, because in most cases, they don't even know what these numbers mean, or what they should do now that they have them.