Margaret Ornsby

Local Search Expert
Joined
Jul 22, 2013
Messages
503
Reaction score
231
Hi all,
I'm beating my head against a brick wall with G local at the moment with a dietitian that has 6 different locations within the same city.
She has separate landing pages for each location, and ranks #1 organic and #1 local for dietitian+location for all but one location.
The problem for me is that because she practices out of doctor's clinics, G has twice decided to confuse her dietitian listing with the listing for the doctor office.
For each of her locations the business name listed is "dietitian company name - doctor's clinic name", and she has a single number for all locations. This number is distinctly different from the doctor clinic number.
Because the offices are small, the street addresses are the same (identical) to the doctor office.

If I search for "doctor practice name" the knowledge-graph comes back with the dietitian's listing. People then call the dietitian because they can't read the screen...;)

I'm confused by the behaviour of combining two business listings together simply because they have the same address. Google has always been able to handle different businesses at the same address. The business names are different from the doctor's and the phone number is different.

This has now happened twice, about six month's apart. So it's not just a temporary glitch...

Renaming the dietitian business name to only her practice didn't stop Google from confusing the two businesses the first time, so I'm not sure whether I should drop the naming convention "dietitian company name - doctor's clinic name".

There are no suites or room numbers in her locations, she's simply using one of the practice offices. So even if I put a fake suite number in there, it's not really the address.

Any suggestions?
 

Linda Buquet

Moderator
Local Search Expert
Joined
Jun 28, 2012
Messages
13,312
Reaction score
4,241
Hi Margaret, this is so complicated. Hope it's OK but since you don't mention any names or links, I want to move to public so others can benefit from all the things I'm going to try to share. (Hardly anyone will see it in the private forum.)

Since this is fairly rare and unique (a specialist working inside various Drs offices) I'm going to have to draw parallels to other types of listings in order to try to explain all this.

1) If lets say it was a regular Dr office with 6 Drs we recommend never naming the Dr listings Practice Name: Dr name. Because if they all have practice name in them they are all competing PLUS there is increased chance Google will merge them.

So name needs to be her name.

2) Even with a regular multi-location business, each location needs it's own phone. If all her locations are the same phone, it's a problem.

3) This is almost a situation like a container store. Starbucks within Safeway. That requires setting it up a little differently, but I don't think that's really the solution.

4) She's competing with and will get confused with the Dr listing by the algo I would think.

And it's tricky. Here is how the algo COULD see it. It's against the rules for a business to have different listings for each specialty. For instance a spammy aggressive attorney sets up a different site and phone for BK attorney, Criminal attorney, Divorce attorney. But it's really one business at one location. Not allowed.

How would the algo know this is not the Drs just setting up a separate listing for their dietitian specialty?

5) If all her locations are in same city, they are all just competing with each other and she likely won't rank for all of them anyway.

6) So the algo will get confused on 2 fronts and tend to merge or rank drop due to either the name issue or the phone #s all being the same.

Q: Does she have a main office she works out of? When she is not seeing pts and is just scheduling, doing books, etc, where is she??? I would think best thing might be one listing with service area???
 

Margaret Ornsby

Local Search Expert
Joined
Jul 22, 2013
Messages
503
Reaction score
231
Thanks for replying, Linda. And yes, this is complicated.

I posted this in private initially just in case you wanted to see links. Can provide specifics if you think that will help resolve the issue - let me know and I'll create a new thread there.
I'll go thru the each of the points...

1) She's not the sole practitioner in her business. She is the owner and one of four, all running under the same company name. So each of the locations is hercompanyname - dr clinic name.
EG: her company name - Adept Dietitians. Dr clinic names: Riverside Clinic, Greenvalley Clinic, CityCentre Clinic. All 3 Dr clinics independently run. Her business listings are: Adept Dietitians - Riverside Clinic, Adept Dietitians - Greenvalley Clinic, and Adept Dietitians - CityCentre Clinic. Each clinic is independent and each has one of her part-time dietitians working there. (names have been changed to protect the innocent...)

2) Tried this - individual phone numbers not an option (non-negotiable) for her. I know it's not best practice, but its what I have to work with. This hasn't been a problem up until very recently, but even then, G's not merging her listings together, it's merging hers with the dr clinic which *does* have a local number. G's showing a strange preference there.

3) Yes, sounds very much like a your example of a container store. Perhaps that's the solution? Have I missed something in the training about setting this up differently? Could you point me in the right direction please?

4) Taking this approach, in theory if I simply stripped the clinic name from the Google page - perhaps then Google would get it right? That creates a problem with my citations/directory listings... will have to investigate to see if I can create a workaround.

5) All her locations are indeed in the same "city" but by that I mean metro area. Here, though, we're used to the city centre being called the city and the surrounding suburbs being called by their own name. I don't believe her listings compete with each other because the addresses are specific to the corresponding suburbs. If I search for her listing by cat + suburb, I don't get her other listings in the list until after all other listings in that same cat + suburb. At the moment, all bar one location ranks either first or in top 3 plus usu #1 organic. The one that doesn't yet rank is the most competitive and will take a bit more work, and I think I know what needs to be done.

6) Yes, algo getting confused... I think your comments in #4 are the direction of what's happening. Just never occurred to me to think that way - not devious enough in my thinking yet! :eek:

Sadly, she doesn't have a "main office" she works out of. Challenging. She's not a SAB so I hadn't considered the service area. I also don't like my chances of her showing up in "all" the listings for the suburbs. In large part because she can't afford the cost to do the extra work to get one single listing to rank city-wide.
The city/metro area spans roughly 20 miles, 30 miles, and 35 miles from the city centre in varying directions. In other words, a huge area!

Q If I had just one listing for her business with a service area, how would people know the individual locations? They're looking for a local or nearby professional to go visit. They'll check the knowledge-graph and not click on the website (as is evidenced by the number of calls for the doctor's office she's copping). If there's no address they'll move on to the next listing.

At this stage I'm leaning towards making all the pages the same name (taking the doctor clinics out of it) approach. But I'm curious to know more about the container store.

Thanks again - sometimes working on something for a while makes it hard to see the forest for the trees...
 

Linda Buquet

Moderator
Local Search Expert
Joined
Jun 28, 2012
Messages
13,312
Reaction score
4,241
Confused about some stuff still but 1st...

I don't teach about container stores because I've never once had it come up, not even here in the forum. Here is what Google says:

"Some businesses may be located within a mall or a container store, which is a store that contains another business. If your business is within a container store or mall, and you'd like to include this information in the local listing, specify the container store in parentheses in the business name field. For example, Starbucks (inside Safeway)."

But I'm not saying that's the way to go. Just was saying this is almost sort of similar but don't know if it's appropriate for medical.

Confused re locations. You 1st said all same city. Then you said "All her locations are indeed in the same "city" but by that I mean metro area. Here, though, we're used to the city centre being called the city and the surrounding suburbs being called by their own name. I don't believe her listings compete with each other because the addresses are specific to the corresponding suburbs."

Do they all have address in City 1 example? Or are the addresses City 1, City 2, City 3, City 4?

At 1st I thought it sounded like she had offices within other Dr offices she did not own. Now it almost sounds like you are saying those 4 practices are hers too?
 

Margaret Ornsby

Local Search Expert
Joined
Jul 22, 2013
Messages
503
Reaction score
231
Hi Linda,

Oh dear - did not mean to confuse.:eek:

OK, taking your comments on board about containers. Might see if I can do some research about whether it's acceptable to have tenants with their own business inside another business in medical industry (as opposed to coffee shops).

Sorry about the confusion with locations. All locations are in the Melbourne metro area. Large geographic area. Only if your biz/home is in the city centre do you use the "melbourne" as the city. Even if you're just a wee bit away from the city centre, your proper address will be a suburb - eg Prahran, South Yarra, Port Melbourne, Richmond etc, with differing postcodes as well. Yet everyone in these locations are from Melbourne. So her practice offices are "in Melbourne" (as opposed to Sydney or Los Angeles).

You were right at first, she does not own the practices. She rents a room in various doctor clinics. She rents the room under her business name and hires dietitians to man them for her if she does not work there herself. To be clear this is not a practice/practitioner thing going on, clearly a practice only.
 

Linda Buquet

Moderator
Local Search Expert
Joined
Jun 28, 2012
Messages
13,312
Reaction score
4,241
OK I get the location issue now.

But I'm sorry I've never run into this type of situation before. We had discussions with Google awhile back about specialists like a podiatrist using his Dr Name - that works in one Dr office 2 days a week and another office 3 days a week. But that's easier because practitioner listings are allowed.

This is a practice within a practice so I'm not sure. I do know though that they should not be dual named with both practice names and ideally each location needs a different number.
 
Joined
Apr 25, 2013
Messages
41
Reaction score
10
One thing you might want to check (if you haven't already) is the listing information on Google Mapmaker. It tends to keep a history of all the names a listing has had in the past, and I've seen that cause a couple of duplication errors before.
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
Cherie Dickey Is anyone else noticing a change to the "Suggest an Edit"? Google News: Important Changes & Features 23
sixthcitysarah Can anyone recommend a Digital PR agency/freelancer? Local SEO Job Board 3
nathangdavidson Does anyone know if there's a GMB Category for vaccination centre? Google My Business & Google Maps 8
Steve Attarian Has anyone had luck removing a Review by a non customer that gave one star because she noticed that the staff didn't wear masks when she walked by? Google My Business & Google Maps 4
nathangdavidson Anyone noticed Website fields not being updated in GMB, even though approved? Google My Business & Google Maps 5
sixthcitysarah Anyone know much on in-page PHP coded redirects? Websites, Software, and Security 1
Wary Goose Anyone used the Business Banking Service GMB Category in the U.S. yet? NAP, Categories, Dashboard Data 5
ryannbull We have added a question to our client's Google My Business Q&A section and it keeps disappearing. Is anyone else experiencing this problem? Help & Support for Google Local 4
nathangdavidson Anyone noticing reviews not being added to profiles? Local Reviews 5
nathangdavidson Anyone using Google's Marketing Kit tool to promote reviews? Google My Business & Google Maps 5
Steve Wiideman Does anyone have a Google My Business claiming best practice guide? Google My Business & Google Maps 3
Rich Owings Is anyone having trouble adding users to GMB listings? All Things Google My Business [PRIVATE] (LocalU) 5
DanielTexasLira Has anyone done Local SEO on a Dual Pad Hotel (two different hotel brands sharing the same location)? Local Search 6
Rich Owings Is anyone having trouble adding users to GMB listings? Help & Support for Google Local 2
Caroline S Maps Results Moving Down The Page? Anyone Else Seeing This ? Google My Business & Google Maps 2
brettmandoes Is anyone having trouble transferring listing ownership to a new account? Google Duplicates & Merges 1
Matthew Summers Anyone else see a big change in "blue links" rankings starting around 5.26.20? Google Algorithm Discussions 0
sixthcitysarah Has anyone received Google Ads credits yet? Paid Search and Local Service Ads 23
Steve Wiideman Anyone Heard of Nearby Now? Websites, Software, and Security 2
Ben Walsh Anyone have any experience with GMB briefcase? Ask a LocalU Expert [PRIVATE] (LocalU) 5
Ben Walsh Anyone else seeing a bunch of pending review statuses in GMB? Local Search 6
Hammer Anyone else get notified that their recent post was taken down (but wasn't)? Google My Business & Google Maps 1
G Renesent Reviews - Anyone Familiar With These Guys? Local Reviews 3
Toby 39 Celsius Any feedback? GMB Profile reported repeatedly...now cannot get anyone to review and reinstate Help & Support for Google Local 4
J Has Anyone Experienced Automatic Suspension After Verifying Location Local Search 6
dave101 Anyone have Good Examples of a GMB listing with a good Q&A section? Google My Business & Google Maps 0
Simon Cox Anyone seen a Stay Verified email from GMB before? Google My Business & Google Maps 4
T Has anyone had success reporting schema spam to google? Spam on Google 5
Chaddow Anyone have experience of using Yandex Business Directory Local Search 18
Chaddow GMB restaurants recent change is anyone else seeing this role out Google My Business & Google Maps 4
sixthcitysarah Anyone seeing changes to URLS, categories, or descriptions reverting out of nowhere? Google My Business & Google Maps 15
M Anyone here doing CPA Marketing with success? Marketing 0
M Anyone else having problems with LocalFalcon autoscans being incomplete? Local SEO Tools & Software 0
dave101 Anyone have experience with optimizing IT Support companies? Service Area Businesses 0
dave101 Anyone a Yext Reseller? Local SEO Tools & Software 8
kathleen.rhodes Does anyone have experience with eClincher for posting to GMB (and social sites)? Local SEO Tools & Software 1
M Anyone here doing Affiliate Marketing please? Marketing 5
S Anyone else seeing huge traffic spikes? Google My Business & Google Maps 3
Tim Colling PlePer - is anyone here using it? Local SEO Tools & Software 8
C GMB Bulk Upload Problem - Anyone else with the same issue? Google My Business & Google Maps 3
dave101 Anyone reselling Grade.Us Local Reviews 6
Jen Currier Is anyone else seeing a delay in the publication of responses for Google Reviews? Help & Support for Google Local 0
Chris Ratchford Anyone familiar w/ Advanced Custom Fields (for WordPress)? Consultant's Corner 6
J Anyone notice these factors on Google Local Search since the update? Local Search 5
Dan Foland Is anyone else noticing Google displaying more consecutive same-site results? Google Algorithm Discussions 6
J Wondered if anyone has a list of businesses that trigger the maps Local Search 2
Chaddow Google Maps Driving Directions Update ? Has anyone seen this Google My Business & Google Maps 4
dlee325 Apple Maps erroneously marking businesses as Closed - Anyone else have this issue? Local Search 4
H Does anyone recognize this Report format? Consultant's Corner 3
S Has anyone seen improved rankings from doing GMB posts consistently? Google My Business & Google Maps 14

Similar threads

Login / Register

Already a member?   LOG IN
Not a member yet?   REGISTER

Most UpVoted Answers

LocalU Podcasts

  Promoted Posts

New advertising option: A review of your product or service posted by a Sterling Sky employee. This will also be shared on the Sterling Sky & LSF Twitter accounts, our Facebook group, LinkedIn, and both newsletters. More...
Google Product Exert


Top Bottom