PurpleWeb

Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2017
Messages
18
Reaction score
0
Hi

I am working with a client and over the last couple of months there has been a significant drop in his rankings. In this time a few things have happened.

1. I have added some location based pages targetiing more specific areas. These pages included accordions with service information in them and although i totally rewrote the main page content i forgot about the text hidden in the accordions. I therefore there is a possiblility that it could be a duplicate content issue which i have now rectified two weeks ago

2. I paid for some social bookmarking work to be done and shortly after the work had been completed Ahrefs started to report over 5k of backlinks and majesticseo over 48k. Its worth noting that the drop in rankings had defiently happened well before this work so i know it hasnt been the factor that has caused it. Athought now it may be factor in things improving

3. Following on from point 2 I am looking at disaovowing them but when i look at Gooogle Websmaster Tools i can see that the links are not being picked up by the tool.

So my main questions are

1. If i was penalised for a duplicate content issue, now its been resolved how long should it take to fix

2. Do i still have to disavow even if the links arent showing GWT

I am happy to provide the link to the site to anyone who might be able to adviseme further

Thanks
 

heckler

Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2014
Messages
282
Reaction score
78
1. There's no such thing as a duplicate content penalty on Google. (source)
2. Google won't show you everything it knows about you in GSC/GWT. I'm not sure I'd just start disavowing if the problem started before you used an ancient link-building tactic, it's likely Google is just ignoring those links anyway, but you're adding more variables to your troubleshooting.

Also accordions aren't a bad thing. They help improve mobile experiences; they're completely different from just hiding content (display:none).

To me it sounds like your drop is due to changing your content (based on what you've outlined).

Questions I have:
  • How long ago was the ranking drop?
  • Has traffic to the site from Google also dropped?
  • Did your site structure change?
 

JoshuaMackens

Local Search Expert
Joined
Sep 12, 2012
Messages
1,950
Reaction score
579
Hi

I am working with a client and over the last couple of months there has been a significant drop in his rankings. In this time a few things have happened.

1. I have added some location based pages targetiing more specific areas. These pages included accordions with service information in them and although i totally rewrote the main page content i forgot about the text hidden in the accordions. I therefore there is a possiblility that it could be a duplicate content issue which i have now rectified two weeks ago

2. I paid for some social bookmarking work to be done and shortly after the work had been completed Ahrefs started to report over 5k of backlinks and majesticseo over 48k. Its worth noting that the drop in rankings had defiently happened well before this work so i know it hasnt been the factor that has caused it. Athought now it may be factor in things improving

3. Following on from point 2 I am looking at disaovowing them but when i look at Gooogle Websmaster Tools i can see that the links are not being picked up by the tool.

So my main questions are

1. If i was penalised for a duplicate content issue, now its been resolved how long should it take to fix

2. Do i still have to disavow even if the links arent showing GWT

I am happy to provide the link to the site to anyone who might be able to adviseme further

Thanks

1) While there may not be a duplicate content "penalty", I think that really is splitting hairs. Google will not rank a duplicate content site well. Once you fix the duplicate content, you should see a decent increase in rankings, depending on how much of the site was duplicate content. If it's just internal duplicate content I'm not sure if that is affecting you. If it was external duplicate content then Google needs to recrawl it and everything should be more or less resolved in a few weeks.

2) I'm not sure I would be too concerned about this either but it doesn't hurt to go ahead and disavow. Just make sure you don't blanket disavow sites that might be useful like stumbleupon or whatever real world social bookmarking sites are useful these days.

3) GSC doesn't pick up everything it knows about. In my experience, the high level links will make it into your recent backlink reports. If Majestic picked up 48k links though, Google definitely knows about them. They're just not showing them. I might still consider disavowing them. Especially if they have exact match anchor text.

If you could post the site that would help.
 

PurpleWeb

Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2017
Messages
18
Reaction score
0
1) While there may not be a duplicate content "penalty", I think that really is splitting hairs. Google will not rank a duplicate content site well. Once you fix the duplicate content, you should see a decent increase in rankings, depending on how much of the site was duplicate content. If it's just internal duplicate content I'm not sure if that is affecting you. If it was external duplicate content then Google needs to recrawl it and everything should be more or less resolved in a few weeks.

2) I'm not sure I would be too concerned about this either but it doesn't hurt to go ahead and disavow. Just make sure you don't blanket disavow sites that might be useful like stumbleupon or whatever real world social bookmarking sites are useful these days.

3) GSC doesn't pick up everything it knows about. In my experience, the high level links will make it into your recent backlink reports. If Majestic picked up 48k links though, Google definitely knows about them. They're just not showing them. I might still consider disavowing them. Especially if they have exact match anchor text.

If you could post the site that would help.

Thanks for your reply. I have messaged you URL.

Thanks
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
James Watt Questionable Advice on recent Search Engine Land article Google My Business & Google Maps 20
cleverlyengaged Advice on Landmarks/POI/Unclaimed Google Map Locations? Google My Business & Google Maps 6
sixthcitysarah Advice for Dental Office Buying Closed Practice? Google My Business & Google Maps 4
coachmarino Advice for Suspended Listing? Google My Business & Google Maps 3
raellovepie Reported GMB keeps coming back. Need Advice Spam on Google 1
J Advice Needed - GMB Listing Visibility Issues Help & Support for Google Local 7
B SAB With Virtual Address - Advice Needed Help & Support for Google Local 4
Nicole Basham Multi-service Service Area Business: GMB Optimization Advice Needed Service Area Businesses 2
AdamB In need of advice - Spam listing keeps reappearing Spam on Google 16
rutkap Spam Help/Advice Needed Spam on Google 20
ValerieM Advice Local Directory Listing Service - Suggestions or Advice Citations 24
M Advice needed can I have my GMB cake and eat it? Multi-Location Issues 3
Colan Nielsen [Examples Needed] GMB Support Offering Ranking Advice Google My Business & Google Maps 2
P Creating local city pages near to my branches advice Local Search 4
Tim Colling Facebook Page Merging advice Mobile & Social 21
C Multi-Location Keyword Targeting - Looking for Thoughts / Advice Multi-Location Issues 0
chrish Multi-Location Keyword Targeting - Looking for Thoughts / Advice Multi-Location Issues 4
D Need advice on a bad reviews from competitors Local Reviews 7
BaggySEO Some advice on a bad review please Local Reviews 3
H My Advice on Chamber of Commerce Links Local Search 1
brownaddesign GMB Business Hours - Need Advice Google My Business & Google Maps 3
P Advice on URL Redirects Local Search 2
SEOExpertBrad Could use some advice dealing with a Local GMB spammer.... Local Search 2
W Google Reviews Removed - Any advice welcomed Local Reviews 10
P Hyphen In Domain / Domain name advice ? Local Search 4
J Just Starting Out As A Freelance Content Writer. Advice Is Welcome. Consultant's Corner 4
djbaxter Need advice. Google post card sent. Now client says no mail delivery there. Help & Support for Google Local 3
Tilak Advice on Firm Names vs Website Local Search 2
T Advice on National Brands Local Search 12
J Got a brand domain but should I register a PMD to help rank ? Any advice please :-) Google My Business & Google Maps 4
M Need advice with this MCF Google My Business & Google Maps 0
Mike NCM Need advice on converting a 'blackhat' site to 'whitehat' Local Search 6
Linda Buquet Google My Business Finally Adds Advice for Working w/ SEO Companies - Joy Hawkins Google My Business & Google Maps 2
J In Local Pack for most keywords but NOT main keyword , any advice please Help & Support for Google Local 7
H Organic Penalty Advice - your thoughts Local Search 3
J Advice Needed on Client My Business Listing and Maps Help & Support for Google Local 5
web50local Need Advice: Same Business Name, Different URLs and Locations Local Search 4
Jim Froling Great advice from Phil Rozek Consultant's Corner 4
JoshuaMackens UBL/Advice Interactive Merger Google My Business & Google Maps 4
H Multi - location advice: call center and phone number Multi-Location Issues 5
H Multi - location advice: call center and phone number Multi-Location Issues 5
D Need some advice Help & Support for Google Local 7
M Google Local Listing Advice Service Area Businesses 5
MarketingGiant Google Local Listing Advice Service Area Businesses 5
Linda Buquet Your best Local Search ranking advice? In just one sentence. GO! Local Search 38
dani Seeking advice about 2 Local listings Help & Support for Google Local 6
R Seeking Advice - Possibly Hijacked Email Break Room: Chat and Off Topic 2
M Client's site is over-optimized (urls, footer, anchors). Need advice! Local Search 11
brentnau Advice To Remove False Review Google My Business & Google Maps 4
shondarogers Advice on Advertising on Yelp vs Google Express Local Search 5

Similar threads

Login / Register

Already a member?   LOG IN
Not a member yet?   REGISTER

Most UpVoted Answers

Trending: Most Viewed

LocalU Podcasts

  Promoted Posts

New advertising option: A review of your product or service posted by a Sterling Sky employee. This will also be shared on the Sterling Sky & LSF Twitter accounts, our Facebook group, LinkedIn, and both newsletters. More...
Google Product Exert


Top Bottom