Joined
May 3, 2018
Messages
148
Reaction score
218
I have a question that sort of merges two ideas:

1.) I've seen arguments that citations from sites with a higher DA are more valuable.

I know Rand Fishkin developed DA with his grandfather (I think I read that story in Rand's book "Lost and Founder") and that it's not an official Google measure. I also understand that it's based on the PageRank model, which is all about backlinks.

Citations, which might not have a backlink at all, lend to Prominence. (i.e. repeated mention of a business)

So, I think DA is a reasonable proxy but not a golden rule.

2.) Google looks at other review sites to get an overall rating for a business. Which other review sites Google examines varies by industry. However, these other review sites show up in the knowledge panel, so you know what Google is looking at.

We know the words in reviews from other sites create an association between the business and those words. That helps a business rank better when those words are in a search query.

So, it makes sense to me that any review site Google displays in the KP is worth using for review diversification.

1.) + 2.) See the SERP in the screenshot below. This shows the KP for the only pet shop in a small town. It includes a rating from Canada247 | Find businesses and places which is a typical business directory.

DA=1

Based on DA alone, some might argue that it's a useless citation.

Given that Google is pulling it into the KP makes me think it's valuable.

Interesting case!

Thoughts on DA for citations? Thoughts on picking sites for review diversification? (I've obviously presented my opinions. Looking for supporting evidence and conflicting thoughts!)

4170
 

Phil Rozek

Local Search Expert
Joined
Jul 26, 2012
Messages
1,885
Solutions
12
Reaction score
1,457
@Stefan Somborac, here are the main things I pay attention to:

1. Does the site rank somewhere on the first couple of pages of results for a search term you care about?

2. Does the site rank on the first page (or two) of results when you search by name for a specific high-ranking competitor?

3. Can customers write reviews on it? (If so, often the answer also is "yes" to points #1 and #2, or to both.)

Also relevant are questions like whether anyone uses the site, and whether it offers a link that passes PR. But those are down the list of concerns.

I wouldn't pay attention to DA, partly because most directories have high DA, even if they're crappy sites in every other respect.
 

Yan Gilbert

Administrator
Moderator
Local Search Expert
LocalU Faculty
Joined
Oct 15, 2016
Messages
452
Solutions
1
Reaction score
520
Given that Google is pulling it into the KP makes me think it's valuable.

I agree with that.

I never look at DA, but a few other things I tend to check is if the citation page is indexed, and/or if it is showing as a backlink in Search Console.
 

JoshuaMackens

Local Search Expert
Joined
Sep 12, 2012
Messages
1,950
Reaction score
579
I have a question that sort of merges two ideas:

1.) I've seen arguments that citations from sites with a higher DA are more valuable.

I know Rand Fishkin developed DA with his grandfather (I think I read that story in Rand's book "Lost and Founder") and that it's not an official Google measure. I also understand that it's based on the PageRank model, which is all about backlinks.

Citations, which might not have a backlink at all, lend to Prominence. (i.e. repeated mention of a business)

So, I think DA is a reasonable proxy but not a golden rule.

2.) Google looks at other review sites to get an overall rating for a business. Which other review sites Google examines varies by industry. However, these other review sites show up in the knowledge panel, so you know what Google is looking at.

We know the words in reviews from other sites create an association between the business and those words. That helps a business rank better when those words are in a search query.

So, it makes sense to me that any review site Google displays in the KP is worth using for review diversification.

1.) + 2.) See the SERP in the screenshot below. This shows the KP for the only pet shop in a small town. It includes a rating from Canada247 | Find businesses and places which is a typical business directory.

DA=1

Based on DA alone, some might argue that it's a useless citation.

Given that Google is pulling it into the KP makes me think it's valuable.

Interesting case!

Thoughts on DA for citations? Thoughts on picking sites for review diversification? (I've obviously presented my opinions. Looking for supporting evidence and conflicting thoughts!)

Value of a citation or review site.JPG


I agree with everything you said.

I also think it's about leverage. To me, if it costs $10 per directory, do I want to be put on 350 directories? No. If it costs 1 cent, do I want to be put on 350 directories even if their metrics (DA, etc.) are low? Absolutely. The same goes for time. If it takes me 15 minutes per directory sign up do I want to sign up for 350 directories? Heck no. If it takes me 1 second per directory? Absolutely.

I don't think you need to worry about if a directory makes sense or not if you can leverage well. If you can't (which is often the case), then yes, you do need to pick and choose. And the criteria you laid out is a good way to pick and choose.

But with the inexpensive services out there for citations these days, I think you can leverage relatively well and not have to worry if you should or shouldn't waste your time or money getting on a site. When you leverage well, you hardly use any time or money.

Also, I'm going to dissent on DA. I do look at DA. If all things are equal and DA is the difference between a 1DA site vs a 100DA site, yes, by all means, choose the 100.

While DA is not PR, it's a good indication of the popularity of a site. I use it as a relative metric, not a hard and fast metric. A site with a DA of 40 could actually have a lower PR than a site with a DA of 30. But I would be willing to bet money that a site with a 100DA has a higher PR than a site with a 1DA, if you catch my understanding.

So I definitely use DA. But only as one metric among many.

But for citations you also need to consider things others have mentioned such as indexing, does it show up in SERPS, etc. as well as whether the link is followed/nofollow.

My whole point though is the conversation about "how many citation sites should I be on" is really moot if you leverage.

But I agree with your original post. Your thinking is right on.
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
L Best Citation Sites to Update & Obtain Reviews On Local Search 8
whiz Is local ranking just on-page, location, citations and reviews? Local Search 4
Linda Buquet Score a Quadruple Local SEO Win - Appointments, Citations, More Reviews + Backlinks Local Search 18
Linda Buquet 50 Leading Local Review/Citation Sources in the US Citations 3
F Google Maps Citation confusion? Google My Business & Google Maps 3
valentinb13 GMB uses residential address—but client wants to use PO Box for other citations... Citations 3
Elmer .S What is the most accurate search strings to use when doing manual citation audit? Citations 7
JohnnyM Changing Information in citations Google Local 101 1
DragonXD SEMrush and citation service in Denmark NAP, Categories, Dashboard Data 4
SpectateSwamp Long Business Name & Citations Recycle Bin 0
TriciaClements Long Business Name & Citations Citations 9
JoshuaMackens Insurance Citation Sites Local Search 5
K Law Practice Buyout and Existing Citations Citations 4
sixthcitysarah What citation sites would you say are still important in 2020? Citations 10
N Should I use a GMB Website to get a citation and links? Google My Business & Google Maps 2
F Looking for Italian citations services Citations 7
Mike Yem Automotive Department Citations Ask a LocalU Expert [PRIVATE] (LocalU) 1
C Client with multiple address across citations and web properties All Things Google My Business [PRIVATE] (LocalU) 3
Gordon.Ligon SAB vs Physical Address, and its ramifications for NAP citations Service Area Businesses 7
Monica Simpson Optimizing Name - do citations matter? All Things Google My Business [PRIVATE] (LocalU) 7
Dana Franks Changing HTTP to HTTPS in citations Citations 6
Oliver Keates Looking for new citations in 2020 for the UK Citations 4
H Quick questions about citations (newbie here) Citations 2
LocalSEODat Using UTM for GMB link to website. Does that mess w/ citation matching, rankings or anything negative effect? Google My Business & Google Maps 5
bernilocal Looking for France citations service ? Citations 8
C Cheapest Citation NAP Correction Service Citations 16
P Change of Address - Do We Update Citations? Citations 2
P Schema Markup - SameAs - Using these for citations for branches Citations 14
C Website URLs for Multiple locations in Google My Business & Local Citations Google My Business & Google Maps 2
M Fake Map Listings Auto-Created by Citation Service? Spam on Google 6
Craig McBreen Citations for service area business Citations 16
V Question: Bring something to foreign citations Help & Support for Google Local 2
K Customer wants to add a tracking number across all of his Citations NAP, Categories, Dashboard Data 3
Oliver Keates New Citations Local Search 6
Travis Van Slooten Using Home Address for GMB and UPS Address for Citations?? NAP, Categories, Dashboard Data 10
Colan Nielsen Announcing "Social Poster" from Citation Builder Pro LSF News and Announcements 0
M Does it make sense to backlink from local citations.... Local Search 7
A Citation Value? Citations 10
Travis Van Slooten What are the 12 Core Citations Every Business Needs in 2019? Citations 16
Travis Van Slooten How Do You Find Niche Specific Citation Directories? Local Search 7
Gsmithmike Would You Create Location Pages, or Use Home page to create citations? Local Search 1
eshad GMB and Citations for SABs Google My Business & Google Maps 1
M Problems listing with some Citations Citations 38
K Not The Best Practice for a GMB / Citations Name Change...and I need opinions. Moving or Name Changes 3
Dana Franks Best citation correction service? Citations 7
K Differences in backlink profile with same citation service Organic SEO 1
Jeffrey Taylor Website Redirects on Citations Moving or Name Changes 2
raellovepie Value of Citations? Citations had little to no impact? Citations 29
abrandt QUESTION: City-specific / Hyper-specific Citation Software ??? Citations 17
CraigJMount Linking from Citations w/ CID's Local Search 7

Similar threads

Login / Register

Already a member?   LOG IN
Not a member yet?   REGISTER

Most UpVoted Answers

Trending: Most Viewed

LocalU Podcasts

  Promoted Posts

New advertising option: A review of your product or service posted by a Sterling Sky employee. This will also be shared on the Sterling Sky & LSF Twitter accounts, our Facebook group, LinkedIn, and both newsletters. More...
Google Product Exert


Top Bottom