Joined
Jul 11, 2014
Messages
23
Reaction score
0
Just wondering if anyone could give me feedback on why this listing is ranking in position A. Besides the amount of reviews, any other insight why this one shot to the A position?

The site is: losangelescriminallawyer DOT pro {Linda removed live anchor text link}

And here's a screenshot of the local results for "Los Angeles Criminal Defense Attorney"

Screen Shot 2014-09-07 at 11.47.09 AM.png

Screen Shot 2014-09-07 at 11.47.09 AM.png
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Linda Buquet

Moderator
Local Search Expert
Joined
Jun 28, 2012
Messages
13,312
Reaction score
4,241
Hi Mariano,

Just having lots of reviews doesn't really put you on top usually.

I just took a quick look but what jumped out at me is how many times Los Angeles was on the home page. Excessive KW density really for all his keywords.

Plus Los Angeles 3 times on G+ Local page.

Plus of course it's an EMD with Los Angeles in it. (Now we know at least that a .pro domain can rank. That's the 1st time I've ever noticed one out in the wild.)

So I see major KW over-optimization - which I've noticed Pigeon likes a lot. I guess more traditional ranking signals talked about with Pigeon means going back 10 years to the heavy KW stuffing days. :(

Have you done back link competitive analysis? That could be it too. I've seen a few people saying BLs seem to count for more in local now.
 
Joined
Jul 11, 2014
Messages
23
Reaction score
0
Hi Linda,

That's what is weird about it. He doesn't rank on the first page organically.

But he ranks on the A spot for Local. That's why I find it so weird.

---------- Post Merged at 02:28 PM ---------- Previous Post was at 02:23 PM ----------

His Google + page also has 265,000 views, which I find a little on the high side.
 

Linda Buquet

Moderator
Local Search Expert
Joined
Jun 28, 2012
Messages
13,312
Reaction score
4,241
"He doesn't rank on the first page organically."

Oh now that's interesting. Didn't realize that. Didn't check that deep.

But you are right - that's pretty odd.
 
Joined
Jul 19, 2012
Messages
32
Reaction score
18
Interesting. I've not seen a .pro ranked so highly.
Quick word on backlinks. The .pro has over 17K backlinks with 7k each (14K total) coming from Los Angeles Criminal Defense Attorney Blog — Published by Los Angeles & Southern California Criminal & DUI Defense Attorney and Los Angeles DUI Attorney Blog — Published by Los Angeles & Southern California Criminal & DUI Defense Attorney Michael Kraut

As Linda points out, it appears to be excessive geo-local kw usage, but maybe this is working post pigeon. At least for now. Things are still in flux.

Since he is on the Map Pack, I'd suggest studying his citation profile using Bright Local, Whitespark or Places Scout to see if there are any advantages.

Best of luck!
 
Joined
Feb 5, 2013
Messages
124
Reaction score
33
Have you done back link competitive analysis? That could be it too. I've seen a few people saying BLs seem to count for more in local now.

When you say BL's seem to count for more now does that mean the links to the specific URL that is provided on the G+ biz listing or total links to the site?

I am asking b/c after Penguin 2.1 in October of last year a client of ours was hit hard. Dramatic drop in organic rankings BUT they remained in the Local packs, to my surprise! Without notice their previous "SEO" firm had redirected all their microsites to the new site and unfortunately we were not aware of this until after the drop in rankings.

The majority of the microsites were redirected to the homepage and city pages. Prior to developing the site I asked to create specific pages for Local for better tracking and NAP consistency, so the URL's that are on their G+ listings (that are still ranking well in Local, even after Pigeon) have roughly 8% of the links the city page has, that was previously ranking well in organic.

Something I have been wondering about....:confused:
 
Joined
Feb 5, 2013
Messages
124
Reaction score
33
Confused yet? Me too when I recently was researching a variety of terms.

If the top 3 positions are usually influenced by organic rankings what is going on here for the term "Dallas Electrician"?



Screen Shot 2014-09-08 at 6.53.28 PM.png

I know, as Linda says, the pigeon has not landed yet so I am not looking for an answer on this, just thought it was interesting that a business that ranks 1st organically did not make it into the Local pack.

Screen Shot 2014-09-08 at 6.53.28 PM.png
 

JoshuaMackens

Local Search Expert
Joined
Sep 12, 2012
Messages
1,950
Reaction score
579
Just wondering if anyone could give me feedback on why this listing is ranking in position A. Besides the amount of reviews, any other insight why this one shot to the A position?

Here's the site: Los Angeles Criminal Defense Lawyer - Los Angeles DUI Attorney - The Kraut Law Group serving LA, Pasadena, Beverly Hills, Glendale and Burbank

And here's a screenshot of the local results for "Los Angeles Criminal Defense Attorney"

Capture1.jpg

He has a Penguin penalty. Penguin penalties will affect organic listings but will not affect the local pack. The local pack ignores them. It creates a type of buffer.

Almost any time you see someone ranking high in the local pack but not anywhere organically, they're under a penguin penalty.

When you say BL's seem to count for more now does that mean the links to the specific URL that is provided on the G+ biz listing or total links to the site?

I am asking b/c after Penguin 2.1 in October of last year a client of ours was hit hard. Dramatic drop in organic rankings BUT they remained in the Local packs, to my surprise! Without notice their previous "SEO" firm had redirected all their microsites to the new site and unfortunately we were not aware of this until after the drop in rankings.

The majority of the microsites were redirected to the homepage and city pages. Prior to developing the site I asked to create specific pages for Local for better tracking and NAP consistency, so the URL's that are on their G+ listings (that are still ranking well in Local, even after Pigeon) have roughly 8% of the links the city page has, that was previously ranking well in organic.

Something I have been wondering about....:confused:

Hey Amber,

Same thing as above. October 4th I believe was Penguin. Sounds like they got hit but the local pack buffer kept them in the local pack ranking.
 

Broland

Member
Joined
Aug 8, 2012
Messages
136
Reaction score
85
I don't have time for any analysis in any kind of depth right now but I did want to add one thing to what has been questioned/said.

Often times if a site has an algorithmic penalty such as Penguin, it will still rank well in pack results. But there is also something Google uses called the diversification of search results by merging (Worth looking up if you want to read about it.) Most of you have seen it in action, basically merging the organic and local listings to only display a domain or page once per SERP result. This factor/algo gets tweaked at times (usually with updates) and you will see changes.

Not so long ago it was much much easier to break down the local places rankings separate from organic rankings and figure a lot of things out with different tricks/searches in the Google Places search, but that's gone now and I think that is in Google's favor and best interest of combating spammers and SEO's.

So I'm not saying it is or isn't, but not ranking organically while ranking in the pack doesn't necessarily mean a penalty. Remember every SERP is different too.
 

JoshuaMackens

Local Search Expert
Joined
Sep 12, 2012
Messages
1,950
Reaction score
579
I don't have time for any analysis in any kind of depth right now but I did want to add one thing to what has been questioned/said.

Often times if a site has an algorithmic penalty such as Penguin, it will still rank well in pack results. But there is also something Google uses called the diversification of search results by merging (Worth looking up if you want to read about it.) Most of you have seen it in action, basically merging the organic and local listings to only display a domain or page once per SERP result. This factor/algo gets tweaked at times (usually with updates) and you will see changes.

Not so long ago it was much much easier to break down the local places rankings separate from organic rankings and figure a lot of things out with different tricks/searches in the Google Places search, but that's gone now and I think that is in Google's favor and best interest of combating spammers and SEO's.

So I'm not saying it is or isn't, but not ranking organically while ranking in the pack doesn't necessarily mean a penalty. Remember every SERP is different too.

I did not know about that Broland, great find.

While I do a Penguin analysis on all the websites I believe to be under the penalty, you will need to do it yourself to make sure that you're seeing an issue because of Penguin and not because of what Broland mentioned.

For the record, every SERP I've seen so far where a company is in the local pack but 4 pages deep organically or more, a Penguin penalty has been the culprit.

If someone would like me to do a guest blog post for them on detecting Penguin penalties or anything else related to this, I'd be happy to. I'd put it on my own blog but my audience is local businesses, not SEO's so it would be too advanced for them and confusing.

PM me and let me know!
 

Linda Buquet

Moderator
Local Search Expert
Joined
Jun 28, 2012
Messages
13,312
Reaction score
4,241
Wow Ben and Joshua, you guys are really sharing great insights!
Just shared this post and called you two out on Twitter and G+!

Thanks for the great food for thought!
 
Joined
Aug 1, 2012
Messages
64
Reaction score
25
A little late to the party but I will put my 2 cents in anyway. I have noticed that, not only what Linda said earlier about the keyword density, but sites that tend to rank in the maps pack usually have the Google+ page linked in some way. Either through the publisher tag hidden on their site, or an icon linking them to the + page. This is just giving Google what they want and allowing them to add information to the knowledge graph.

Obviously this is not the only way to rank on the front page maps pack. However, it's a start.

It also seems that we've forgotten the time when Google had separated the Map Pack and Organic results. Way back when we were talking about "Blended" map listings that take into consideration all signals, map and organic, to create one nice page.
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
R Free Webinar: Local SEO Guide Google Ranking Factors for 2019 Events 0
CharlotteSEOExpert On-Page Local SEO Strategy for Quicker Rankings Local Search 0
Linda Buquet NEW! Local SEO Ranking Factors Study 2017, Have you studied it? By @localseoguide Local Search 1
J Some Local SEO tips for ranking in London? Local Search 0
DanLeibson 2016 Local SEO Ranking Factors Deck from SMX Advanced Local Search 34
Linda Buquet Hot Webinar: Top Local SEO Ranking Factors in 2015 Local Search 5
T Local SEO, National Website, Ranking for Multiple Keywords Consultant's Corner 1
Linda Buquet Local SEO: Which Performs Better - High Pack or High Organic Rankings? Local Search 10
jessewheel Re: Local SEO Ranking Expert Survey - How Long Does It Take? Recycle Bin 0
Linda Buquet How to Leverage your Competitors for Local SEO to get High Rankings Local Search 3
L Multi-Location Local SEO - How U-Haul Keeps 17,000+ Locations Ranking Multi-Location Issues 4
Linda Buquet Multi-Location Local SEO - How U-Haul Keeps 17,000+ Locations Ranking Multi-Location Issues 4
M Local SEO - Why is this ranking so high? Ranking Puzzles 11
Dustybones 2014 Local SEO Expert Survey: How long to Rank Local Search 5
johncrenshaw Awesome Local SEO Ranking Tip to Grab #1 Spot Local Search 53
Michael S. Doran Does a forwarded domain hurt local SEO ranking? Local Search 6
Linda Buquet Local SEO Ranking Puzzle + Important Lesson! Local Search 8
D Re: Local SEO Ranking Expert Survey - How Long Does It Take? Recycle Bin 0
Marie Ysais Ranking Practices by Local Major SEO Companies Local Search 2
Linda Buquet How Google Hummingbird Impacts Local SEO & Local Rankings Local Search 1
Linda Buquet Google Maps Update - Shifts the Rankings, Impacts Local SEO Google My Business & Google Maps 8
Linda Buquet How Long to get Local SEO Ranking Results? Answers Inside Local Search 17
Linda Buquet Local SEO Roadmap to Success - Research to Boost Rankings Local Search 5
Linda Buquet Welcome to the Local SEO & Ranking Forum Local Search 0
Linda Buquet Local SEO Takeaways from Yelp - Top Ranking Local Listings Local Search 2
Linda Buquet Local SEO Ranking Expert Survey - How Long Does It Take? Local Search 13
L Local SEO Ranking Game - Why Ranks High? Ranking Puzzles 46
Linda Buquet Local SEO Ranking Game - Why Ranks High? Ranking Puzzles 46
Shelly Pros & Cons of Facebook Locations for Local SEO (for a Credit Union) Multi-Location Issues 3
rich_marlatt Do the number of backlinks from a domain have any impact on local SEO? Local Search 2
Annika Neudecker One year later, is your GMB/local SEO traffic still up? Local Search 3
djbaxter New Local SEO tool from BrightLocal: Local Search Grid Local SEO Tools & Software 7
F Turkish post: Google My Business local seo Recycle Bin 0
F Google My Business local seo Google Local 101 3
Kayla Adam Canadian Local SEO Agency Needed Local Search 3
shively Microsoft Clarity (Local SEO heatmap tool) Local Search 2
djbaxter Take the 2020 Local SEO Blackbelt Quiz Events 0
C The value of a blog on a website for local SEO Local Search 58
N Local SEO for Franchisee Local Search 4
DanielTexasLira Has anyone done Local SEO on a Dual Pad Hotel (two different hotel brands sharing the same location)? Local Search 6
georgebizpro What are your favorite on-page local SEO tactics? Local Search 2
Monica Simpson Local SEO Professional ZOOM - July 17th Events 6
Andrew Shotland Local SEO Guide is Hiring a Sr Director of SEO Local SEO Job Board 0
Monica Simpson Last Local SEO Zoom Friday July 10 Events 0
Monica Simpson Local SEO Zoom - June 25th LSF News and Announcements 0
Monica Simpson Local SEO Zoom - June 19th Events 1
Monica Simpson Meet Local SEO professional via Zoom Local Search 1
Monica Simpson Local SEO Zoom Meetup Local Search 1
djbaxter Local SEO Experts You Need to Follow on Twitter Local Search 0
Monica Simpson Local SEO Zoom Meetup Events 1

Similar threads

Login / Register

Already a member?   LOG IN
Not a member yet?   REGISTER

Most UpVoted Answers

Trending: Most Viewed

LocalU Podcasts

  Promoted Posts

New advertising option: A review of your product or service posted by a Sterling Sky employee. This will also be shared on the Sterling Sky & LSF Twitter accounts, our Facebook group, LinkedIn, and both newsletters. More...
Google Product Exert


Top Bottom