Marie Ysais

Member
Joined
Sep 18, 2012
Messages
242
Reaction score
51
I saw another here in the forum talking about proximity algo lockout. Linda, said it isn't much of a problem today. But I was wondering is there a sure way or method to test if you are to far from the centroid to rank in places? Or is this an issue you wouldn't worry about today?
 

Colan Nielsen

Administrator
Moderator
LocalU Faculty
Joined
Jul 19, 2012
Messages
3,770
Solutions
4
Reaction score
1,909
With the blended format and the higher emphasis on on-site optimization I see many businesses who are on outskirts of a city and still ranking. Often better than businesses that are much closer to the centroid.

Not too sure if there is any sure way to test.

Interesting question!
 
Joined
Jul 23, 2012
Messages
496
Reaction score
144
Hi Marie,
While I don't know of a sure-fire test, basically, what I do is to perform a generic (non-branded search) in maps.google.com. Let's say my client owns a restaurant serving Italian food in Piedmont, CA. So, I would search for 'italian restaurant piedmont ca'. What one often can see is a cluster of businesses near one another with mainly high letter rankings. If your business is far away from this cluster, it could be slightly disadvantageous, but, as Colin says, there are tons of businesses way beyond the cluster that rank just fine.
 

Linda Buquet

Moderator
Local Search Expert
Joined
Jun 28, 2012
Messages
13,312
Reaction score
4,241
1 second what both Colan and Miriam said.

Echo Colan in that it's mainly blended these days which is more about on-site SEO strenth and you can rank far outside the centroid. See example below.

Plus I kinda do what Miram does, but differently. I search on regular Google and check to see how far out the ranking cluster goes.

My fav example illustrates both points above.

Seattle Chiropractor. Check the map. The A listing is WAYYYY north of the city. You can see the primary cluster and how they are mainly downtown but E and A break out and rank.

But when the proximity lock out was in effect that map was zoomed in so tight that it only showed downtown listings. Even cut off the map so the current E listing was cut out of page one and that one is only about a mile from downtown. It was very clear at that time looking at the map that if you weren't inside that tight map radius you were out of luck.

For a blast from the past, here's the examples I showed of the proximity lockout in Oct 11.

<center><a href="http://marketing-blog.catalystemarketing.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/10/SeattleChiroCompare21.jpg"><img src="http://marketing-blog.catalystemarketing.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/10/SeattleChiroCompare21.jpg" alt="" title="SeattleChiroCompare2" width="510" height="490" class="alignnone size-full wp-image-2729" /></a></center>

But again now it's different and with enough organic strength you can rank even on the outskirts of a city.
 

Marie Ysais

Member
Joined
Sep 18, 2012
Messages
242
Reaction score
51
Thanks for the great input! I live in an area that is in the outskirts and of course everyone wants to rank in the big city! What I am finding on the map is the companies North of the City in the outskirts are ranking on the maps but not the companies South of the city. Your tips are great and helps a bit when trying to see if a client has a chance to rank.
Thanks for posting the example. I was looking at another example you put in the forum on the same topic yesterday (Linda) and it was another great example!!
 

Dave

Member
Joined
Nov 19, 2012
Messages
254
Reaction score
78
Linda;

It seemed to me, when the "proximity algo lockout" was being observed, it was more a case of google randomly changing and testing different "location prominence" perspectives with Maps showing in google.com. At times they responded to a search with a geo description for Seattle with smb's JUST inside the city borders. At other times they expanded the location prominence and included significant suburban areas for the Seattle region (and other regions). I thought it was a matter of testing.

Now if you had a business in the suburbs, and the "location prominence" or "proximity algo lockout" was in effect with TIGHT borders that focused only on the city...you were out of luck, no doubt.

In my experience its one of those things out of our control, as google has continuously tested different ways to show results, and similarly it tests the responses over huge volumes of data.

Really the only way to "beat" something like that is with the prominent and powerful strict SEO for a phrase such as "Seattle Chiropractor" so strong that regardless how much geography the Maps/Pac wishes to show you have a listing that sits above the Pac.

At least that is my $0.02. :D
 
Joined
Jul 18, 2012
Messages
477
Reaction score
96
I haven't tested this myself but what about this scenario...

Does Google skew the results based on your specific IP address? Example: I live in Blaine, MN - a north suburb of Minneapolis, MN. If I search for "dentists minneapolis mn" would I tend to get G+ local results that skew on the north side of Minneapolis - vs. someone conducting the same search in the heart of Minneapolis, MN (who might see results almost entirely in the centroid)?

Travis Van Slooten
 

Marie Ysais

Member
Joined
Sep 18, 2012
Messages
242
Reaction score
51
Good Point Travis. I can tell you that I am very south and my searches still show me the city and north of the city. I don't get any south results. But now you have me very curious so I will have to test this out a bit.
 

Dave

Member
Joined
Nov 19, 2012
Messages
254
Reaction score
78
I haven't tested this myself but what about this scenario...

Does Google skew the results based on your specific IP address? Example: I live in Blaine, MN - a north suburb of Minneapolis, MN. If I search for "dentists minneapolis mn" would I tend to get G+ local results that skew on the north side of Minneapolis - vs. someone conducting the same search in the heart of Minneapolis, MN (who might see results almost entirely in the centroid)?

Travis Van Slooten

Travis: I can't speak for that phrase in particular but I do test and retest for certain of our smb's with regard to certain phrases, again and again. I test by resetting the location for different suburbs around a central city. The smb picks up traffic all around the metro region for a variety of phrases. Clearly on some phrases rankings and the pac change subject to location. On other phrases nothing changes.

Its really subject to each phrase and the strength of any particular page for that phrase, all within the geo territory.

at least in my experience
 

sergiuliano

Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
107
Reaction score
33
Hi Travis,


Usually the ISP local IP data is not the correct one. In case you live in the north part of the city but the ISP set all IPs on the South Part and Google will rely on this factor, then your results will be from a different city area than your current location.

Also is not clear enough where are you running the searches?

- on google organic search
- on google maps/places
- or google local ?

because each one is providing different rankings

Same time device is important as mobiles are sending to google "GPS data" and in this case the results are much more accurate.
 

Chase Billow

Member
Joined
Sep 19, 2012
Messages
46
Reaction score
7
^ That's a good point. When you get a chance, dig in to your StatCounter data and check out your own "City". You'll notice it is often not exact and can even change within the same day.
 
Joined
Jul 18, 2012
Messages
477
Reaction score
96
:eek: So my simple question is actually more complex than I realized...lol. I can't imagine being the team that has to create these algorithms...lol.

Travis Van Slooten

Hi Travis,


Usually the ISP local IP data is not the correct one. In case you live in the north part of the city but the ISP set all IPs on the South Part and Google will rely on this factor, then your results will be from a different city area than your current location.

Also is not clear enough where are you running the searches?

- on google organic search
- on google maps/places
- or google local ?

because each one is providing different rankings

Same time device is important as mobiles are sending to google "GPS data" and in this case the results are much more accurate.
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
Mike Yem Review Proximity All Things Google My Business [PRIVATE] (LocalU) 2
TomGuard Local Ranking Better in Proximity to Verification Address Service Area Businesses 5
snysarah Does address change impact proximity signal if it's hidden? Service Area Businesses 13
Tim Colling So now, which wins: physical proximity or service area? Local Search 5
T Proximity in Local Search Rankings Local Search 8
F Zip Code, Proximity & Ranking Factors Local Search 1
Dillon Brickhouse How Proximity (and ZIP codes) Impact Local Rankings Google My Business & Google Maps 2
JoyHawkins Google Just Rolled Back the Possum Proximity Filter Google My Business & Google Maps 3
DanLeibson Proximity is the new Yeezy Local Search 0
elwalker Is Proximity to the Center of a Search Location a Ranking Factor? Google My Business & Google Maps 4
C Proximity from centroid enough to keep someone out of the map pack? Google My Business & Google Maps 1
D How to Determine If Proximity Is a Ranking Factor for Any Keyword Local Search 16
Nick.SEOSpark Questions regarding "Proximity of Address to Centroid" Factor Local Search 12
rustybrick Local Algo changes? Google Algorithm Discussions 5
Jon Cahen Dentist Algo Change? Organic SEO 2
K Huge Spike In Views & Searches Around September '19 Algo Update Google My Business & Google Maps 2
L Significant google algo change in the last few days? Organic SEO 4
JoyHawkins October 3, 2018 - Google Medic Algo Update - How Did It Affect Local Businesses? Google Algorithm Discussions 4
JoyHawkins Re: Social Media Signals and Google August 2018 Core Algo Update? Recycle Bin 0
Nikos Knowledge Panel Removed - Possible change in algo? Local Search 23
JustinB Snapchat's Algo Update - Who here uses snap chat for digital marketing? Local Search 1
Linda Buquet 3 Months In: Measuring the Impact of the Google Mobilegeddon Algo Mobile & Social 1
Linda Buquet Major Google Local Algo Changes - No it was a BUG, Now Fixed Google My Business & Google Maps 36
Linda Buquet Google to Tweak Pigeon Algo due to Racial Slurs & Google Map Search??? Google My Business & Google Maps 8
Margaret Ornsby Google deep learning and the local algo Google My Business & Google Maps 4
Linda Buquet Google Warns about Doorway Page Algo Update - Could Affect Local Google My Business & Google Maps 16
Margaret Ornsby Here's an interesting view of the algo... Google My Business & Google Maps 1
Linda Buquet Pigeon Algo: Advice from Top Experts and a Checklist Google My Business & Google Maps 0
Lloyd Silver Any changes to best practices for real estate agents due to latest Google Local algo Google My Business & Google Maps 5
Linda Buquet Pigeon Analysis - New Insights about this Crazy Google Local Algo & the Constant Flux Google My Business & Google Maps 50
Linda Buquet Major Google Local Algo Update - Google "Pigeon" Update Shakes it Up! Google My Business & Google Maps 145
Linda Buquet 4 Hot Local Ranking, Local Algo Analysis & Competitive Research Tools Compared! Local SEO Tools & Software 8
Linda Buquet Google Quality Rating Guide Leaked - Deep SEO Insights: How Google Algo Works Now Organic SEO 6
H Different Algo for "City + Keyword" vs "Keyword Only"??? Local Search 1
Linda Buquet Google Local Algo Shake Up - Are You Seeing Changes in the 7 Pack? Google My Business & Google Maps 13
Linda Buquet Google Local Algo Change or Did Spam Filters Get Dropped? Google My Business & Google Maps 10
R Blended Algo? Local Search 3
Linda Buquet Reverse Engineering the Google Local Algo Local Search 3
Colan Nielsen Google Local SERP Update: Old Pack Algo & Doubles Google My Business & Google Maps 50
Linda Buquet Re: Attack of the Bad Google Local One-Boxes? Other Algo Changes? Recycle Bin 0
Linda Buquet How the Google Local Algo Really Works - What Rules the Ranking Order Google My Business & Google Maps 29
Linda Buquet Hidden Listings, Local Ranking & Algo Changes with the New Google Maps Google My Business & Google Maps 11
Linda Buquet Reverse Engineering the Local SEO Algo to Steal #1 Local Search 4
Linda Buquet HOT! Track SERP Changes & Reverse Engineer Algo with Update Scanner Local SEO Tools & Software 7
Linda Buquet Major Google Local Review Improvements! Better Algo = More Reviews Local Reviews 20
Matt Dec 18 Google+ Local Algo Update? EMD Comes back strong? Local Search 12
Linda Buquet Build Google+ FILTER Bubbles NOT Links - The Algo is Curating our World Local Search 0
Linda Buquet Guide to Handling Ranking Drops and Google Algo Changes with Clients Consultant's Corner 0
T Responding to Reviews and the Local Algo Local Search 3
Linda Buquet New Google LOCAL Algo Changes - Here's the Scoop Local Search 1

Similar threads

Login / Register

Already a member?   LOG IN
Not a member yet?   REGISTER

Most UpVoted Answers

Trending: Most Viewed

LocalU Podcasts

  Promoted Posts

New advertising option: A review of your product or service posted by a Sterling Sky employee. This will also be shared on the Sterling Sky & LSF Twitter accounts, our Facebook group, LinkedIn, and both newsletters. More...
Google Product Exert


Top Bottom