@morganbloom FYI HighLevel is a marketing/crm platform that agencies use with their customers.
I happened to know the previous account I had set up with HL so I was able to be specific about the agency account the GBP was attached to, hopefully you already sorted it out, but if not you may need to track down the main email (or name) for the agency that these GBPs were connected through on HighLevel.
I had to get in touch with HighLevel support at the start of this year to decouple my own GBP from LeadConnector (it was something that had to be done via their dev team and they wouldn't share any details about what caused the problem) . . . I can recognize it by that default avatar image.
It's super strange that there is no option to sever the connection from the GBP end, usually you can suspend permissions with third party products that have been authorized, but not in this case.